News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Hacker News Guideline: Avoid Gratuitous Negativity by tptacek on Friday April 03, 2015 @05:20PM (#9318612)
Since "you can happily go fuck yourself" is not in fact an argument, the principle of charity does not demand that you interpret it as anything more than a rude interjection. At its strongest, it would require you to assume that the commenter was legitimately upset and deeply invested in the argument, which would perhaps keep you from responding in kind.
Re:New Hacker News Guideline: Avoid Gratuitous Negativity by dragonwriter on Friday April 03, 2015 @05:26PM (#9318663)
> At its strongest, it would require you to assume that the commenter was legitimately upset and deeply invested in the argument

I don't think even at its strongest the PoC would require you to assume that the commenter was legitimately upset, only that the commenter was intending to express that they were upset.

The PoC only applies to interpreting what the intended message is, not to conclusions about its justification as would be necessary to support the interpretation that the commenter was legitimately upset.