News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by sp332 on Monday November 09, 2009 @02:34PM (#931568)
Isn't reverse engineering also protected against by patents?
Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by grellas on Monday November 09, 2009 @02:47PM (#931593)
Yes, it is.

The patent system is predicated on the idea of disclosure (indeed, the very word "patent" derives from a Latin word meaning "open"). The idea is that inventors will add their innovative knowledge to the public domain, for which they will receive a temporary monopoly on its commercial exploitation.

Most proprietary software is protected by trade secret laws, which are vulnerable to reverse engineering. Patented software is not, since it has already been disclosed in the public record and is nonetheless protected during the term of the patent by virtue of its monopoly status.

Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by anonjon on Monday November 09, 2009 @02:59PM (#931619)
Sure, of course.

I guess my point is: Think of the patent debate as a continuum where at one end you have 'strong patents' and at the other end you have 'weak patents'.

At the strong patents end you have a prevalence of IP trolling. At the weak/no patents end you have a prevalence of reverse engineering and heavily reduced incentive to innovate (might as well just copy and produce/market cheaper/better). IP trolling and reverse engineering are kind of edge-case exploits.

It isn't clear to me that anything in the middle of the continuum (defends against both edge cases) is really consistent with what we think of as a patent, or that there is anything in the middle that is actually possible enforce in a fair and consistent matter.