Re:Why I keep fixing my bike
by blacksmith_tb on Friday April 03, 2015 @01:49PM
(#9317278)
While it's true that concept originated with Campy (which is why we're still calling it a "gruppo" after 40+ years), but Shimano owns an enormous chunk of the bike component market, more than 80%, so they have really made incompatible product lines into a way of life for the industry (with some sniping from SRAM, who make Shimano-compatible parts that often work better than the originals; I have a SRAM chain on my other wise Shimano drivetrain, for example).
That's why you can't just replace one element of the drive-train with a random other, you'll have to find a compatible piece and this can be quite hard after a bike gets older and that particular 'group' is no longer supported or serviced.
The idea behind a group is that chain, front and back dérailleur and the two sets of gears form a unit which work well together. The main driving force behind this is that if you add or reduce the number of gears on the pinion you're going to want a wider or narrower chain which affects the dérailleurs.
So there is some logic behind it but it can indeed be very frustrating to have to replace all of the drive train just because one small part is impossible to source.