News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by frik on Thursday April 02, 2015 @02:15PM (#9312409)
The clustered beneath the pi-tail of the NASA/MIT D8 design is bad for maintainability, isn't it?

All we learnt from early commercial jetliner like the De Havilland Comet (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Havilland_Comet), where two pairs of turbojet engines were buried into the wings, is that such configuration increased the structural weight and complexity of the wings. Armour had to be placed around the engine cells to contain debris from any serious engine failures; also, placing the engines inside the wing required a more complicated wing structure.

Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by Sanddancer on Thursday April 02, 2015 @03:41PM (#9312698)
Trijets have been around for a very long time, and aside from the DC-10's various misfeatures, have been rather reliable, even when the number two engine goes out with or without detonating itself in various ways. Given that this plane will almost certainly be fly by wire, I imagine that it'll be a lot easier to design the hydraulic systems in ways to further avoid certain failure modes that did occur in those planes.

Regarding maintenance, the article discusses how the reverse design gives a benefit of having the parts of the engine most difficult to service in a position to make such service easier, so I imagine maintainability will be /different/ but not necessarily worse.

Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by frik on Saturday April 04, 2015 @03:49AM (#9320292)
Trijet design will almost always consume more fuel than a comparable twin engine design. This results in higher operating costs and reduced range. Although trijets are more efficient than four-engine aircraft, the difficulty and complexity of mounting the center engine through the tail will somewhat negate this advantage.

quote from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trijet

Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by rdtsc on Thursday April 02, 2015 @04:40PM (#9313074)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-154

Is also a popular trijet. Not only that but one of the fastest passenger civilian aircraft. It is on its way out and in limited operation.

Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by nether on Thursday April 02, 2015 @04:47PM (#9313114)
Much of the downsides of burying engines in the wing versus in the fuselage (below the H-tail) are irrelevant because the engines are not in a cantilever loaded portion of the structure. A beam has zero bending moment at a free end, and we may treat the fuselage as a long beam with free ends, like a see-saw balanced on a fulcrum in the middle (the wing in this case; we are neglecting the downforce from the horizontal tail). Placing the engines at a far end of the minimizes the bending load they must withstand. Placing engines at a wing root means putting them at the location of maximum bending moment due to the lift acting on the wing.
Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by usefulcat on Thursday April 02, 2015 @02:25PM (#9312495)
The article addresses debris-related engine failure mitigation.
Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by Shivetya on Thursday April 02, 2015 @03:50PM (#9312751)
I would still think that intake at the top of the fuselage should be less likely to ingest debris, the military would be an ideal means to test it in transport configurations.
Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by Sanddancer on Thursday April 02, 2015 @04:07PM (#9312855)
There's been a decent amount of research that the upper portions of the fuselage are more durable locations for engines. The A-10 for example, has its engines located up and to the rear for that reason, and the experimental YC-14 [1] also had the engines placed up high, albeit for different reasons, but avoidance of ingestion was definitely a nice side effect.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_YC-14

Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by scrumper on Thursday April 02, 2015 @03:20PM (#9312591)
Only in as far as a novel 'core canting' approach to protecting one engine from an unconfined failure of the adjacent unit. It didn't discuss protecting the tail or fuselage (unless I'm forgetting something; read it a couple hours ago so maybe I did.)
Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by frik on Thursday April 02, 2015 @03:31PM (#9312636)
Yes the second engine may be saved (not mechanically linked).

But the debris could destroy parts of the tail/wing/fuselage.

Re:Pratt and Whitney's Next-Gen Geared Turbofan and the “Dou... by nether on Thursday April 02, 2015 @04:51PM (#9313136)
This is a tradeoff due to mission priorities. Embedded nacelles (as in fighters) reduce drag (the point of this project is to increase efficiency), but complicate matters of structural support and increase engine vulnerability in case of fire. These have superior shielding to runway debris and birdstrikes, but such incidents are extremely rare.