"LUKS" stands for "linux unified key setup" and it is an "on-disk format" and its reference implementation is found in cryptsetup[1]
LUKS on-disk format is supported in windows through doxbox[2]
cryptsetup also supports TrueCrypt,the on-disk format.
people usually say "LUKS" when they mean cryptsetup as it makes no difference to them but i think its important to know the difference.
[1] https://gitlab.com/cryptsetup/cryptsetup/wikis/Specification
Just use PGP, probably the gpg [0] software. You can set it up so that each machine knows the others' public keys, or you can take a shortcut and copy the same private key to all your machines. Encrypt and decrypt as you like. This is "hacker" advice, however; gpg is not a consumer-oriented tool. You'll have to read some documentation and keep your wits about you. But that was true of TC as well, wasn't it?
Just to be clear, I appreciate your suggestion, and in many cases it is entirely sufficient.
But for me, right now, TrueCrypt hits kind of a sweet spot in terms of portablity, convenience and security.
If there's a replacement for this use case I'd really like to know about it.
Ditto:
If you're using FDE for your system disk, it is desirable to know that in the event of the OS becoming unbootable that you can open it using any old OS. Especially in the case of laptops, where you won't have any guarantees about what other machines are available.
As I said - it's a whole lot better than nothing. The "insecure" thing is mainly to remind myself that it isn't the be-all and end-all.
It would be relly nice if there was some common container format you could mount natively on these operating systems without the need for 3rd party software. I think I remember reading about LUKS supporting TrueCrypt's container format - but that, of course, only works on Linux. And frankly, I don't see Apple and Microsoft either supporting the TrueCrypt container format natively or getting together to define a new one.
Plus, BitLocker is not available on Vista Business and Windows 7 Pro. So if you don't want to use Windows 8, again, you are kind of screwed.
[1] At least it was/is the only software that I know of which allows you to do that. If there are alternatives, I would very much like to hear about them!