The fact that this attack doesn't pass even a most cursory risk/reward analysis.
Anyone with the technical smarts to carry it out must be well aware that there is zero upside potential for China. The targeted projects are not gonna disappear, github is not gonna disappear.
All possible outcomes are negative; The targeted projects get extra media attention (Streisand effect), the "Cyberwar" narrative in the west is fueled (cf. this HN thread), in the worst case there could even be a minor diplomatic quarrel with the US.
What do they have to win here?
Github is up and running after all. Both targeted projects are online:
https://github.com/greatfire
https://github.com/cn-nytimes
Looks like if you want to mess with China then all you have to do is put your material on Github. You think that is the lesson China wanted to teach the world?Lets not forget this wasnt an easy thing for github to handle. Their service still isnt running at 100% normal. Not to mention the cost burden they're currently dealing with.
Was there any doubt about China's ability to blast sites much bigger than Github off the internet to begin with?
They're the second largest economy in the world. They don't need to play painfully obvious MITM tricks on their own infrastructure to carry out an attack - which then doesn't even have enough oomph to make a dent on a large but probably not particularly hardened site.
Lets not forget this wasnt an easy thing for github to handle.
That doesn't change the message that this random, half-assed neck-slap sends.
If this was really done by Chinese authorities and if I was a Chinese dissident then I'd be thrilled rather than chilled. Who knew keeping my stuff online could be as easy as uploading it to Github!
Do you really think anyone concerned with these things (activists, VPN providers, companies doing business with China) needed a half-assed, unsuccessful Github attack as a "deterrent signal"?
Interestingly, this also gives China more bargaining power in its negotiations with the US about "cyber" issues
Why would the US Government be concerned about "chinese attackers" that apparently can't even take out a civilian top100 website?
Interestingly, this also gives China more bargaining power in its negotiations with the US about "cyber" issues
You mean they will offer to stop "pretend attacking" american companies, and the US will then make concessions out of gratitude?
The potential gain is that they can extend this capability (and chilling effect) to GitHub and other sites that aren't under the sovereign control of China. Nobody wants to go out of business just because a user uploaded a file which is politically controversial in China. Now every company will think twice and come up with some weaselly reason why they can't have text files about Falun Gong or whatever.
You mean like Github did in this very case? Except wait, they didn't.
So who is this "every company" that will now "think twice"?
the overwhelmingly most likely suspect for the source of the GitHub attacks is the Chinese government.
Why would the "Chinese government" carry out an open attack against an american company for absolutely no potential gain at all?
Do you really think they are stupid enough to believe such an attack could remove these two software packages from the internet?