News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pin-pointing China's attack against GitHub by peterwwillis on Thursday April 02, 2015 @11:02AM (#9311071)
> While many explanations are possible, such as hackers breaking into these machines, the overwhelmingly most likely suspect for the source of the GitHub attacks is the Chinese government.

Correlating the circumstantial facts that China has a giant firewall, the content being blocked is getting around China's firewall, and an attack came from somewhere deep in one of China's largest backbone providers, does not make an 'extreme likelihood'; it makes a weak correlation. Likelihood requires reviewing known outcomes to determine a likely result. What other known evidence of specifically these three behaviors by the Chinese government are you basing this conclusion on?

> This is important evidence for our government.

You've taken a massive leap in logic from a machine inside China manipulating global traffic to attack servers in the US, to conclude that it is more likely to have been the Government than anyone else. This is exactly the same as saying any attack originating from the US which appears to be related to US interests must be from the US government. If this was the basis for how we concluded all investigations into illegal actions, anyone who 'looked like' they did it would be found guilty, sans evidence. That may be how other nations' justice system works, but not ours.

Furthermore, in no way is either Github or Baidu's analytics considered 'key US Internet infrastructure'. I mean, Git is even a decentralized system - people can still get work done if it's down!

This is not evidence of the Chinese government's complicity, and pretending it is creates a dangerous logical fallacy that could improperly shape public opinion.

There are no comments on this comment yet.