News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The ‘Tsar Bomba’ Was a 50-Megaton Nuke by tim333 on Thursday April 02, 2015 @05:25AM (#9309481)
The trouble with the 100% yield version that was originally planned is it would have dumped a lot of radioactive fallout on Russia. The 50% version was not so much dialled back as a different design with some of the uranium components replaced with lead.
Re:The ‘Tsar Bomba’ Was a 50-Megaton Nuke by Symmetry on Thursday April 02, 2015 @07:07AM (#9309888)
Thank goodness. I'm also glad they tested it high enough up to prevent the fireball from touching the ground. With a modern bomb you get fallout from the primary stage but the vast majority from an air burst is going to be from the outer uranium-238 shell which absorbs all the extra neutrons from the fusion and splits without emitting any neutrons itself. This isn't a problem with lead for reasons I don't understand and with the air near the bomb you're just doing stuff like turning nitrogen into carbon-14. The results either decay immediately or last for a thousand years and so aren't particularly radioactive. If a bomb goes off near the ground or sea water then there's plenty of stuff possible products with those nasty intermediate half-lives.
Re:The ‘Tsar Bomba’ Was a 50-Megaton Nuke by m_mueller on Thursday April 02, 2015 @08:11AM (#9310137)
Well, lead is a very stable element from what I understand. Radioactive elements like Uranium are radioactive because they're inherently unstable, such that fission is 'easily' doable and releases a lot of surplus energy.
Re:The ‘Tsar Bomba’ Was a 50-Megaton Nuke by Symmetry on Thursday April 02, 2015 @08:36AM (#9310248)
Yeah. I just don't understand why lead can't be turned into an unstable element by bombarding it with neutrons.
Re:The ‘Tsar Bomba’ Was a 50-Megaton Nuke by drostie on Thursday April 02, 2015 @09:19AM (#9310490)
Looking it up in a reference, natural lead is about 1% Pb-204, 24% Pb-206, 22% Pb-207, and 53% Pb-208. These are all of the stable isotopes.

If Pb-204 absorbs a neutron it turns into Pb-205, which isn't stable but its half life is ten million years so it's only very weakly radioactive. The -206 and -207 turn into other stable isotopes, of course. So those don't matter so much: about half of your neutrons enter lead nuclei which can safely absorb a neutron.

The other half, the Pb-208, turns into Pb-209. Pb-209 is radioactive with a surprisingly short half-life of 3.25 hours, so that's gone in a matter of weeks.

The nasty stuff is the lead atoms which happen to absorb two different neutrons during the explosion. This becomes Pb-210, which has a half life of 22 years: short enough that it's going to be emitting a bunch of radiation, long enough that it won't be gone after a few weeks.

So the answer is probably "it's very rare in these sorts of explosions to have two neutrons hitting a single lead nucleus." There are other possibilities (maybe they got the lead from spent nuclear fuel or centrifuges or something and it's all Pb-206) but that sounds like it's the most plausible.

Re:The ‘Tsar Bomba’ Was a 50-Megaton Nuke by Symmetry on Thursday April 02, 2015 @09:59AM (#9310678)
Ok, I did a bit of research. It seems that Pb-208 has a very small absorption cross section for neutrons so you'll probably see very little Pb-209.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_cross_section

http://www.ncnr.nist.gov/resources/n-lengths/elements/pb.htm...