News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Does the Nash equilibrium promote communism? by bertramm on Monday November 09, 2009 @02:00AM (#930540)
I disagree with the above description of a Nash equilibrium. My understanding of such a thing is: When a Nash equilibrium exists each player's best strategy to the others create a "equilibrium" point, or a point from which you don't deviate. In a sense a change in government creates a change in game, not necessarily a Nash EQ. A Nash EQ in a society with a generally "Capitalist" economic, with supporting legal statutes, potentially result in players robbing, stealing, or cheating. However, in a game in which "Communism" is the economic standard, a Nash EQ may be universal altruism or chaos (my hypothesis to two possible Nash EQ's --not based in observation).Thus it is incorrect to blanketly label "Communism" or "Socialism" as a Nash EQ. In a sense a Nash EQ doesn't care about the morality of its players behaviors only that it is a relative equilibrium which results in best strategies that do not deviate in play.

See this Yale open course: http://oyc.yale.edu/economics/game-theory/.

Re:Ask HN: Does the Nash equilibrium promote communism? by david927 on Monday November 09, 2009 @05:45AM (#930706)
Socialism != Communism. I was saying exactly what you're saying: Capitalism but with legal and social protections; Capitalism with boundaries; and that's what most people refer to when they say Socialism.
Re:Ask HN: Does the Nash equilibrium promote communism? by chrischen on Monday November 09, 2009 @02:09AM (#930547)
What if you consider anarchist society as the game, would then communism be the best strategy?