News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some Problems Shouldn't Be Solved by javajosh on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:17PM (#9298670)
Myst was an example of this, which is why I hated that game. You wondered around this (admittedly beautiful) world with very limited degrees-of-freedom. A button here, a lever there. And when you actuated that DoF anything in the whole fucking world might have changed. Then it was up to you to wander around seeing what changed, and which new DoF's opened up. Wash, rinse, repeat. That was the game of Myst.

If you think about it, the greyed out sharing button (and indeed most infuriating software stories) essentially follow the Myst pattern, but in reverse. An unwanted change has occurred to the state of the world, and you don't know what DoF triggered it.

The password thing is actually a slightly different class of user abuse, embodied by all forms, which is making the user turn messy thoughts into coherent data, which is the essence of work. This data must satisfy a long list of predicates, an invisible gauntlet of tests. (It's even better when the form resets part of itself on error - like when your password is cleared if you don't enter the captcha correctly.)

These are crimes against the user, and truly need to stop. (Although Myst was a big hit so clearly some people really love the abuse.)

Re:Some Problems Shouldn't Be Solved by sjackso on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @05:33PM (#9300062)
I think games like Myst succeed in cases where, when the player changes to the state of the world, the consequences of the change make some kind of sense (be it mechanical, symbolic, imaginative, etc.). If you can follow the wire from the switch to the lamp, then you can reasonably deduce that the switch controls the lamp. If you see a rune in two place, then it's reasonable to draw a connection.

Games (and software!) fail when the connections between elements are too subtle, too complex, or simply too inconsistent, and sorting them out passes from being fun to being work.

Re:Some Problems Shouldn't Be Solved by javajosh on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @05:47PM (#9300130)
> the consequences of the change make some kind of sense

You've never played Myst, have you.