Re:U.S. Supreme Court: GPS Trackers Are a Form of Search and...
by rayiner on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:20PM
(#9298701)
There is a difference between "your information" and "information about you." Not just a legal one, but a epistemological one. AT&T doesn't need your permission to keep track of requests on their network any more than Lowes needs your permission to keep track of who buys a lamp.
That said, this is an issue where nitpicky legal and technical analysis is probably going to take a back-seat to politics. After Riley v. California, it seems quite possible that the Supreme Court is ready to say: "it doesn't matter that Mark Zuckerberg can see all your photos if he wants--the 4th amendment applies to the cloud because we want it to."
Re:U.S. Supreme Court: GPS Trackers Are a Form of Search and...
by diminoten on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @03:08PM
(#9299094)
I agree, the prior rulings are mostly from the pre-internet days, and entirely from the pre-Facebook/AT&T metadata-used-to-track-folks days.
I think the legal theory will change, but it's a good point that this specific ruling doesn't impact that theory.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court: GPS Trackers Are a Form of Search and...
by nickff on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:44PM
(#9297738)
>Obviously we're both not lawyers
rayiner is in the Northwestern law department, so he is likely to be a lawyer.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court: GPS Trackers Are a Form of Search and...
by tptacek on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @01:11PM
(#9298027)
I think he just went to law school at NWU. :)
I'd disagree with that. It's my phone, and the metadata collected by the phone company is done with my consent and under certain terms. If the terms change, I get to change my consent if I want.
It'd be like the FBI sneaking a bug into the lamp I bought at Lowes.
Obviously we're both not lawyers, so there's probably a whole bunch of stuff we're both missing (turns out law is hard).