You're not exactly impartial when it comes to Meerkat: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9269693
The reason companies take venture capital is to facilitate growth. If the company is trending downward three days after funding, especially in the immediate response to a direct competitor, that's a very bad sign, both for the company, and the venture capital firm.
Re:Meerkat is dying
by austenallred on Monday March 30, 2015 @04:40PM
(#9292425)
I never claimed to be impartial. I use both apps and have been following them closely. I think Periscope will win some portion of the market, and Meerkat another. Saying that it's screwed right now, while there's still so much excited activity, is still bunk.
Almost every app's growth slows after a viral launch. In a few days we'll see Periscope's growth slowing as well. That doesn't mean they all die.
"Slow growth" is not the same as negative growth.
Re:Meerkat is dying
by austenallred on Monday March 30, 2015 @04:54PM
(#9292540)
There are more people downloading the app than deleting it. That is still positive growth.
Falling down in the app-store rankings two days after launch is a poor metric to use to determine the future of a company with years of burn still in the bank.
See relevant image of startup lifecycle: http://www.vccafe.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/startup-cur...
you can't really call it a trend with just accounting three days worth of data.
I haven't turned off Meerkap notifications on my phone, mostly out of sheer curiosity, and I am seeing literally hundreds of meerkat streams per day of my followers. Apparently you don't have to be at the top of the chart to get hundreds of thousands of downloads (not to mention the app being featured by the app store).
This is such shitty journalism I can't even stand it. Let's have a substantive discussion about a product, but calling it "dead" is bullshit clickbait and even the author must know it.