If they paid 0% down then they may also have been paying PMI of around 1% on the loan (high risk borrowers effectively get punished twice on interest rates).
Just look at the LIBOR Index (most popular index for ARM mortgages) in 2008 and 2013.
Jan 2008 - 4.18750%
Jan 2013 - 0.84250%
Also your figures seem wrong to me:
http://www.hsh.com/natmo2007.html -- in 2007 a 1 year ARM was over 6% for most of the year, longer ARM loans would have been higher. Most people in 2008 didn't have loans taken out in 2008, but more likely in 2004-2006 when the market was hot and rates were higher.
Incidentally, while the real interest LIBOR rates right now are close to zero, actual mortgage rates are considerably higher, especially on 30y fixed (we got a 15y fixed mortgage because with the difference in interest rates our mortgage payment was only about 40% higher than the 30y option).
My numbers look wrong to you because you are comparing them to your APR. You shouldn't. As I've mentioned before APR = Index + Margin. If index goes down, and margin is fixed, what happens to the APR?
You are correct, most people did not get their mortgages in 2008. But the family we are discussing here did. And for anyone with 5/1 ARM taken out in 2004-2008 the rate would have gone down after the fixed period.
I couldn't understand the gut negative reaction I had to this story. I understand why these programs exist and am not necessarily opposed to them. But I feel that people (within their means) should structure their financial affairs to not have to rely on these programs and not use them unless they have to. Unemployment for college educated workers barely crossed 5% at its worst so the two should not have been unemployed for years.[0]
I would be hard pressed to accept food stamps even if I qualified but I would likely accept unemployment insurance. In that sense, it's funny that food stamps are faux pas, unemployment insurance is acceptable and tax minimization is applauded. Even knowing that, I can't help but hold those same biases though.
[0] http://www.economicpopulist.org/content/what-happens-when-pr...