News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by davidw on Sunday November 08, 2009 @02:14AM (#929006)
Leaving aside whether people like the government to do things for them or not (there are many internet libertarians here who obviously do not), is requiring you to purchase something really that different from just taxing you and purchasing it for you? For instance, I am not happy about having purchased a share of a war in Iraq or numerous other things the government spends my money on.

Also, a point for consideration: you're pretty much required to own car insurance if you want to drive.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by lionhearted on Sunday November 08, 2009 @05:16AM (#929145)
> ...(there are many internet libertarians here who obviously do not)...

The labels seem unnecessary here. You could've said "(there are many people here obviously do not)" - there's plenty of smart people who think this bill is going to be bad for the American federal government and American citizens.

The equivalent would be saying something like, "those internet left-wingers who think everyone should be taxed all the time" -> "internet left-wingers" is unnecessary, as is "internet libertarians". The people who oppose this are just people, not internet people, not labels.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by davidw on Sunday November 08, 2009 @05:17AM (#929147)
Sorry, you're right. Apologies. I think I would have removed that if I'd reread it before wandering off to fix pancakes for breakfast, as it really isn't germane to the point I was trying to make, and with which I'm sure everyone can agree: most of us have things we don't want the government to buy for us, and some of us believe the government should buy very little for us with our own money. I'm just trying to say that between "tax" and "forced to buy" there isn't a large difference, not comment on what I think of the whole thing, which I continue to believe is off topic for this site.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by DanielBMarkham on Sunday November 08, 2009 @08:50PM (#930209)
Not looking for comments or to start a thread, but I just now read a commentary that addresses your "between tax and forced to buy there isn't a large difference"

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/nov/07/obamas-hidde...

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by Zak on Sunday November 08, 2009 @03:13AM (#929057)
If you want to drive, but this would require health insurance simply for being alive, the alternative to which most of us do not consider an acceptable option.

It's also noteworthy that in most states, you can demonstrate an ability to pay for a certain amount of damage in lieu of car insurance.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by swombat on Sunday November 08, 2009 @04:58AM (#929133)
If you don't consider being dead an acceptable option, then health insurance sounds just right for you!

Seriously, this debate only makes sense in a context where you consider health insurance to be an "optional extra". It's not. Health insurance is as basic as roads and garbage collection, fire departments and a police force. Out of the whole developed world, it's only in America that something as fundamental as health insurance is considered an optional extra.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by pmorici on Sunday November 08, 2009 @09:21AM (#929289)
There are people that compost and bring what little trash they have to the dump themselves. There are people that ride bikes instead of driving cars. There are people that are their own fire department. Why is it so had to imagine that health insurance might be optional foe some people.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by swombat on Sunday November 08, 2009 @01:10PM (#929528)
Ok. Doctors don't have to get health insurance.

The rest of us, who can't treat ourselves without external assistance (and also those amongst the doctor who expect that they might at some point get ill enough to require assistance from another human being), the rest of us need health insurance.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by Gormo on Sunday November 08, 2009 @03:16PM (#929727)
Pardon the snideness here, but:

As it turns out, doctors are actually human beings, who are able to form relationships and make arrangements with other human beings, whether or not this takes place within the scope of formal public policy or under the aegis of bureaucratic institutions.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by Zak on Sunday November 08, 2009 @01:47PM (#929591)
People who are not doctors could treat themselves too, if only it were legal.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by docmach on Sunday November 08, 2009 @10:29AM (#929346)
Health insurance is optional. My parents never had health insurance and were always able to pay for medical expenses, even with six kids. I also don't have health insurance and so far I've also had no problems paying for medical care. I don't know where the idea that health insurance is a necessity comes from, but it's not based on fact.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by natrius on Sunday November 08, 2009 @02:21PM (#929640)
Had you been less lucky and encountered medical bills that you and your family couldn't afford, everyone else would have to pay higher prices to make up for your failure to pay. If you want to live in a society where no one will be left to die because they can't pay, then you're going to have to chip in to make that happen. That requires insurance for large medical expenses so no one else has to pick up the tab for you.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by swombat on Sunday November 08, 2009 @01:08PM (#929526)
I know some people who have crossed the road without looking many times, and they're still ok.

I guess looking before you cross the road is also "optional".

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by docmach on Monday November 09, 2009 @11:47AM (#931224)
It is and there is no tax on people who don't have road crossing insurance. It's a risk that you can choose to take. If you choose to not have medical insurance and you can't pay for medical care then you might die, but it should be up to you choose if the risk is acceptable or not.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by swombat on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @06:18AM (#932836)
That's not the argument you previously made. You said "it's fine not to have health insurance because I didn't have health insurance and I'm still ok". That's a severe failure of logic. Anecdotal reasoning when looking at something like health insurance is pretty silly.

Unless you're the kind of person whose plan to get rich is to play the lottery, you need health insurance. At some point, in your life, it is quite likely that you will get very sick, or have a serious accident, or have some sort of mishap that suddenly smacks you with a multi-tens-of-thousands-of-dollars-or-more medical bill. At that point, if you don't either a) have health insurance or b) have lots of money, you're basically fucked.

If you pay the insurance all your life and you never actually get to use it, you should count yourself lucky. Health insurance if the kind of thing you pay every month and fervently hope that you never actually need. But if you do need it, having (good, not the american "we'll drop you if you get too expensive" type) health insurance is quite literally a life-saver.

Finally, if you declare bankruptcy because you can't afford your medical bills (and huge medical bills can happen to anyone), society is paying for your treatment anyway, indirectly. Therefore, it is reasonable to mandate that everyone must have health insurance.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by Gormo on Sunday November 08, 2009 @03:02PM (#929708)
_Medical care_ may be in the same category as roads, garbage collection, police department etc. (although one could argue otherwise: the latter are all examples of public infrastructure, but medical care is in most cases a personal service).

However, health insurance is in no way in the same category as any of the above - insurance is a financial tool, used as a means to achieve a desired end in a high-risk situation. Saying that insurance is absolutely essential is like saying that we can't live without zero-coupon municipal bonds. Sure we can, no matter how important the things they're intended to pay for are.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by Zak on Sunday November 08, 2009 @11:57AM (#929438)
Where I spent most of my childhood, there were no roads for a few miles, no garbage collection, no fire department, and while the area was nominally in the jurisdiction of the Alaska State Troopers, it would have taken at least an hour for an officer to respond. Of course, a total lack of infrastructure would be less than comfortable in a modern city, it's entirely possible to live comfortably without such conveniences.

As for health insurance, the claim that it is necessary is absurd. One could make a much more reasonable claim than health care is necessary, but the question of the specific mechanism by which it is paid for is orthogonal to whether it should be considered a necessity in a modern society.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by roundsquare on Sunday November 08, 2009 @06:22AM (#929180)
If you want to drive, but this would require health insurance simply for being alive, the alternative to which most of us do not consider an acceptable option.

There are a lot of areas in the US (most I'd venture to say...) where driving is essentially a necessity once someone has a full time job. Its not like we have a great public transport system. So while you can technically opt out of driving, its not really realistic to do so in most places.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by roundsquare on Sunday November 08, 2009 @06:29AM (#929184)
you're pretty much required to own car insurance if you want to drive.

My understanding is that you need to be able to cover any damage you cause someone else, not to cover your own car damages.

This doesn't kill the analogy though. If someone goes into the emergency room and can't pay for their service, the taxpayers pay the bill. So, by the analogy, the requirement should be to cover anything that the doctor must do because the cost could fall to the taxpayer.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by bokonist on Sunday November 08, 2009 @11:17AM (#929396)
If someone goes into the emergency room and can't pay for their service, the taxpayers pay the bill. So, by the analogy, the requirement should be to cover anything that the doctor must do because the cost could fall to the taxpayer.

Part of the argument in defense of the bill is that the mandate will save taxpayer money because the uninsured will now be forced to pay their own way. Yet despite this claim, I don't seen any provision for returning this savings to the taxpayer? Where is this supposed savings going? Either it is mythical or it's just going to be eaten up by the bureaucracy.

And also, if the person cannot afford their emergency room bill, they won't be able to afford the insurance either, and thus will get subsidized insurance. So one way or another, the taxpayer pays.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by roundsquare on Sunday November 08, 2009 @01:00PM (#929510)
I see a few possibilities: 1) It reduces the amount of tax money spent on emergency room bills and therefore it gets spent on something of more widespread use. 2) Future taxes would be smaller as a result. Depending on the timing, this could result in a year of double counting for that money. 3) There will be a later provision for returning the money. 4) The bill is gigantic and maybe this issue hasn't made its way into the news (unless you've studied it in detail. I would suspect not because of its length...).

As for your second point, I'm not sure thats true, but I don't have any statistics off hand. It would be interesting to see some comprehensive statistics about how much tax money goes to paying for these things vs. how much money the person makes (adjusted for whatever you want to adjust for).

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by Calamitous on Sunday November 08, 2009 @03:16AM (#929060)
Yes, it is different. Taxes are taken out of money I make or spend. This is funded by fines I owe whatever I do.

And yes, I'm required to get car insurance if I want to drive. Driving is optional. Living is not.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by roundsquare on Sunday November 08, 2009 @05:01AM (#929135)
Taxes are taken out of money I make or spend. This is funded by fines I owe whatever I do.

Sorry, I'm not sure I see the difference. At the worst, this is an increase of 2.5% in your taxes unless you do something (buy insurance) to avoid it. They might well call it a fine but in both cases its just paying a percentage of what you make. You might not like this increase, but thats a separate point.

Let me know if I'm missing something though...

Edit: I think they are calling it a fine so that people will avoid it as much as possible in an effort to make sure people purchase health insurance.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by ckinnan on Sunday November 08, 2009 @06:11AM (#929176)
Just to clarify-- the percentage increase in your taxes is much higher than 2.5%-- a 2.5% new tax rate is probably a 5 or 7% increase depending on your existing tax burden.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by jbarciauskas on Sunday November 08, 2009 @08:47AM (#929254)
That doesn't clarify anything, it took me about 30 seconds to figure out what it was you are trying to say. It's pretty simple to understand the penalty is 2.5% of your income, most people don't think in terms of their existing effective tax rate.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by qeorge on Sunday November 08, 2009 @04:05AM (#929096)
I got the impression that the penalty for not having health insurance comes in the form of a tax (up to 2.5% of income). Am I misunderstanding?