News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Dilbert Is Doomed by ars on Sunday November 08, 2009 @02:07AM (#928996)
> We are nearing the point when computers will be mentally equal, if not superior, to humans.

No we aren't. We are no closer now than we were 50 years ago. The hardware is faster, but the software has not changed. (And hardware is not getting faster anymore either.)

Re:Why Dilbert Is Doomed by natrius on Sunday November 08, 2009 @03:28AM (#929070)
Seriously? We have cars that drive themselves. The realm of tasks that only humans can do shrinks every year. We're not close to computers equaling humans, but we are nearing it.
Re:Why Dilbert Is Doomed by moe on Sunday November 08, 2009 @01:06PM (#929525)
I agree. The interesting question is not when robots will be equal or even superior to humans. The interesting question is when they will be advanced enough to take over a significant portion of labor for cheaper than even a chinese slave worker could.

Looking at what Asimo can do today it seems to me we're not far away from the latter; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9ByGQGiVMg

The physical, mechanics part seems to be mostly sorted out. Robots can walk, run, climb stairs, avoid obstacles, get up when they fall, lift heavy things or operate at incredible precision. It won't be long until they exceed us humans in most physical regards (with a few notable exceptions like smelling or touch-sensitive skin, but imho even that is only a matter of time).

In my opinion the really interesting research is now going into the stuff you see in the video above. Making robots discover and interact intelligently with their environment. This is still a far cry from real intelligence but try to imagine the impact when robots become able to execute simple instructions like "Make me a coffee", "Drag the couch from A to B" or even "Repair the plumbing" without further handholding.

That will be the tipping point for a huge shift in society, akin to the invention of bookprinting or the internet, likely even bigger.

Looking at what we have today I would say that specific vision is just a matter of time. Whatever follows then is in the pudding.

Re:Why Dilbert Is Doomed by thisrod on Monday November 09, 2009 @03:13AM (#930588)
Last week, I heard a talk from one of the engineers doing this. He claimed that the main thing holding back robotics is liability concerns. If someone builds a machine that causes widespread death and destruction, the usual cop-out is to blame the operator for losing control of it. But if a fully autonomous robot goes postal, the manufacturer can't pass the buck to anyone.

Perhaps this will be a real issue, or perhaps robot engineers are a bit too fond of Terminator and 2001. Fear of it is apparently causing real effects. It would be sad if the ultimate reason to employ humans is that it feels good to kick their arses when things go wrong.

Re:Why Dilbert Is Doomed by selven on Sunday November 08, 2009 @06:22AM (#929179)
Depends what you mean by mentally superior. Computers can add billions of numbers a second, work at a very high precision with reflexes measured in nanoseconds, do not have weaknesses like boredom and the need to socialize. If you're talking about creativity and navigating the real world, however, computers aren't there yet.