News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by jerf on Sunday November 08, 2009 @01:26AM (#928960)
It's going to be difficult for them not to enforce it, if something like this actually goes into effect. Getting those who think they can go without insurance to pay into the system is one of the major ways it is going to get paid for.

(It is, objectively, a wealth transfer from young people to old people. I find myself wondering if youth support for the bill would drop somewhat if youth realized what was being done to them. I'm not "old" but I'm past the age where I feel I can go without now, so I guess I'm out of this "youth", but I still don't like it. I am young enough that I don't foresee a single penny of this ever being around when I'm actually old enough to need it, since there's just no way in hell either the current system or this new one if it passes will hold up until 2045.)

One interesting scenario I saw (don't recall where, sorry) pointed out that the entire idea of forcing purchase of coverage like this is very Constitutionally dubious. (Where "dubious" means that I actually can't even come up with an argument I disagree with that the Federal government can do this based on the Constitution.) So it is possible this provision could be struck down, but leave the rest of the bill intact, committing to massive outlays with no way to pay for it.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by elblanco on Sunday November 08, 2009 @03:55AM (#929086)
>I find myself wondering if youth support for the bill would drop somewhat if youth realized what was being done to them.

Probably not since:

a) The youth are the least likely to have insurance.

b) The least likely to be able to afford it (they usually have jobs that make less money).

c) Since they meet both a & b, they'll likely be eligible for the credit/handout that they can use to buy the insurance (if that's still in the plan, hard to keep track of and I don't feel like reading through 80 different versions of a 2000 page bill).

Thus it's more a transfer of wealth into the insurance companies. Even with a public option (which I believe in the last rev of the bill, states could opt out of), most people will probably just end up with private insurance.

> So it is possible this provision could be struck down, but leave the rest of the bill intact, committing to massive outlays with no way to pay for it.

This is probably where this will be in 3-4 years. Which will give lots of opportunity then for the opposition to be able to point out how expensive this all is. sigh Not a really helpful attitude towards engineering a solution, but the GOP hasn't been on top of this issue at all in the last 30 years while every other industrialized country on Earth has at least given it a good go.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by jerf on Sunday November 08, 2009 @11:16AM (#929394)
It's not that hard for even a youth to get a job that gets you past the subsidy provisions... well, at least in a normal economy... but I hear what you're saying. Part of what I'm saying though is it is not just an instantaneous transfer; as "youth" move up into their 30s and 40s, they'll be transferring wealth up the chain, and in their 30s and 40s probably still not needing a lot of medical services on average. It's not just today, it's the next 30 years of your life that you'll be experiencing a high marginal tax rate. Which as we all know, under Democratic theories of economics, nobody ever considers the question of marginal tax rates when making decisions about their jobs, of course.

"Not a really helpful attitude towards engineering a solution, but the GOP hasn't been on top of this issue at all in the last 30 years while every other industrialized country on Earth has at least given it a good go."

Well, I've actually liked the GOP proposals that I've read. Yes, the ones that do in fact exist. (Claims that the GOP have offered no solutions are one of the most blatant lies of the entire process; it's simply objectively false. You may not like them but they exist. Another example of our media being either incredibly biased or totally unwilling to follow up on the statements of politicians.... reader's choice.) It's not particularly relevant because if they had to craft a bill that might actually pass in the real world it would get bogged down in all kinds of crap, but there's so much low hanging fruit in the system that the current bill still manages to fail to address in 2000 pages, such as tort reform.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by elblanco on Sunday November 08, 2009 @09:58PM (#930288)
>Well, I've actually liked the GOP proposals that I've read. Yes, the ones that do in fact exist. (Claims that the GOP have offered no solutions are one of the most blatant lies of the entire process; it's simply objectively false. You may not like them but they exist...

It's funny, during these last few months of the debate, this topic has come up a large number of times among my social group (largely in a community and neighborhood messageboard startd as an alternative to my HOA board and in proper startup fashion now has advertisements).

There certainly are many examples of work done by the GOP in this area in the last administration (mostly around medication pricing), but as to this particular case the GOP has been very late to the party and has brought substantially no ideas to the table until very recently -- generally running and obstructive tactic vs. an alternative tactic.

I believe the alternative bill they presented a week or so ago was political theater mostly. There was no chance on it getting debated, voted on, or really seriously considered (particularly this late in the game), and the party knew that. That's why the opening portions of the bill didn't contain policy, but rather a stream of consciousness of party talking points. They simply wanted to be able to point to it and say "see? our ideas aren't even being considered!" knowing full well that most people won't have tracked the submission date of the bill. David Gergen offered a different but similarly minded analysis today.

What I thought was interesting is that, when I asked people, and threw out ideas almost a year ago now, the right leaning members of my community generally came up with some very good, feasible plans that addressed the bulk of this particular issues (no recision, no denial of coverage, must accept people for coverage even with preexisting conditions, balanced by an open market place, all insurance is moved nationally, breeding open competition etc.). But these weren't offered up by the Party (capital P) until many months later. Instead the Party chose to run a scare campaign that had very little to do with the actual contents of any of the proposed bills (including doing a Godwin and interjecting Nazis, which was clearly the point knew they had no appropriate counter argument in the wings anymore). It was wholly disappointing.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by jerf on Monday November 09, 2009 @12:12AM (#930435)
"I believe the alternative bill they presented a week or so ago was political theater mostly."

Consider http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c111:S.1099: . Note the date. It may not run to 2000 pages, but I consider that a feature, not a bug.

Again, the idea that Republicans did nothing but run an obstructionist campaign is pretty much objectively a lie. What is true is that only their obstructionism was reported in the press. That said, it's not like anything they wrote had a chance of getting passed, I am aware of that, and frankly at this point I'm not a fan of either party on this point as it's pretty clearly a choice between dumb and dumber (reader's choice as to which is which), but the putative "coverage" of Republicans has been blindingly biased. Not that the press has done much more than sit there and twitch feebly every once in a while.

(Further, I'd point out that as a minority, "obstructionism" is pretty much their job. The idea that this is evil rather suspiciously dates to January of this year, for mysterious reasons.)

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by elblanco on Monday November 09, 2009 @01:21AM (#930513)
Nice use of Thomas. I had forgotten about this bill, most likely due to the news media showing me some shiny new thing in a different direction while they hid this one under the rug. But if I'm not mistaken (which I'm more than happy to admit I may be in this case), many of the ideas in this bill were eventually moved into the current Senate bill and the just passed House bill.

But to be honest, the legal documentation is so voluminous and it's a moving target such that I can't keep track of all this. So I may be mis-remembering. The size is certainly a bug.

I would say that it's also bad thinking to think that none of the Republican proposals didn't find their way into the present legislation. I think that there were some good ideas put up by the Party that the Democrats also latched onto pretty fiercely. They claimed it was for bi-partisanship, but I think it's more to appear that they owned all the ideas in this debate.

>(Further, I'd point out that as a minority, "obstructionism" is pretty much their job. The idea that this is evil rather suspiciously dates to January of this year, for mysterious reasons.)

I pretty much agree with you on everything you wrote here except for this and that the obstructionist agenda was purely of the media's making.

I think it's a matter of semantics. "Obstructionism" can be one of a number of things. It can be pure stonewalling and obfuscation, or it can be a presentation of alternatives.

The Republicans in this case were relatively transparent, on my plane trip today I saw no less than 20 Republican backed advertisements against "Health Care Reform" -- unqualified. Some of the advertisements asked questions that made absolutely no sense "will it guarantee I can keep my provider?". Well, lady-acting-like-a-concerned-citizen, I've got news for you, you have no guarantee of that now! And several other examples.

Now the GOP may have been taking a two pronged approach, addressing both senses of "obstructionism", but considering that the agenda I heard came from the GOP itself via paid advertisements and spokespeople/heads of the party like Steele, there really wasn't much made of the alternatives. I would say it was an 80/20 effort.

Re:The House Passed the Health Bill by Daniel_Newby on Sunday November 08, 2009 @11:38AM (#929412)
"One interesting scenario I saw pointed out that the entire idea of forcing purchase of coverage like this is very Constitutionally dubious."

There is no direct way for it to be lawful. It has to be done indirectly using an actual authority of Congress. For instance, they could say "A person shall not engage in interstate commerce unless they buy a policy or pay the fine." I predict this is what they will do; those Congressmen really love that Commerce Clause.

But note that the nondiscrimination amendment requires them to treat all persons equally, regardless of place of residence or incorporation. This means foreigners! If a guy in Cincinnati can't call California without buying insurance, then neither can a Chinaman.

If enforced, this will instantly detonate the entire global economy.

If not enforced, then foreigners will be explicitly elevated over citizens. This is not a recipe for political tranquillity, to put it mildly.