News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America's obsession with STEM education is dangerous by graycat on Sunday March 29, 2015 @01:40PM (#9285690)
The article equates STEM education with technical "skills". This is comparison is absurd and is yet another attempt to set up a straw man in order to knock it down and to scream (borrowing from the movie The Music Man) "Oh we got trouble, right here in River City. Trouble starts with a T and that's rhymes with" an E, and that stands for education. So, in the movie the guy was trying to start a boy's band to sell musical instruments and band uniforms, and the OP is trying to sell courses in philosophy and art history?

To the OP, I would suggest that the STEM fields do better on deep and critical thinking than philosophy and art history.

For the US K-12 scores in math and science and the comparison of those scores with South Korea, Singapore, Finland, etc., I'd say: The claim of the OP on these scores is that US K-12 education needs to do better to catch up with the other countries.

Okay, let's consider that claim: Compare the scores of students in those other countries with the scores of students in the US with recent ancestors from those other countries. E.g., compare scores of students in Finland with the scores of students in the US with recent ancestors from Finland. Then are doing better comparing the schools and not just the cultures. So, in crude terms, will be controlling on country of origin.

Here the OP has yet another straw man erected just to be knocked down.

There are no comments on this comment yet.