Exactly. Having made similar types of robotics interfaces myself, the memory graph for OP probably isn't as complicated/cyclic as you might think: multiple types of frames (at various stages of visualization processing) look into each others' memory buffers for efficiency. It's probably best modeled as an acyclic directed graph where frame objects reference (many-to-many) memory buffers. The problem is that unless you abstract out those buffers into garbage-collectible objects themselves, it's very tempting just to pass a weak reference (like a pointer from JNI) to the buffer owned by an EarlyStageFrame to the processing code in a LaterStageFrame. Thus the segfault when the EarlyStageFrame is garbage-collected.
> It's probably best modeled as an acyclic directed graph
My pet theory is that a good representation for most systems should maybe always be an acyclic directed graph?
Someone should go around sabotaging regular expression parsers and replacing them with PEGs:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parsing_expression_grammar
It is a crime against honest words to try to cram so much logic into so few characters.
I once was told that regular expressions were originally designed for creating AIs. The image I have in my mind is that of graduate students in a dungeon somewhere banging on type writers creating some sort of God box.
Are you saying that cyclic data structures are always a bad idea? So no one should ever make a doubly-linked list?
Or, to take a case from a game I'm working on: I'm writing a set of GUI controls for the game's UI. There will almost always be at least a few controls on screen, so I have a WindowManager object that lives for the entire duration of the application and does, among other things, tasks like telling all of the controls to draw themselves, determining which control has focus, etc. The controls all have a reference to the WindowManager object (or whatever their direct parent is, once I start supporting more complex controls) so they can implement methods like onClick() { parent->removeGroupOfControls(); }
Even though the WindowManager is persistent, the individual controls come and go quite often. So if I was using a GC (I happen to be doing this in C++) that simply threw up its hands whenever it encountered a cycle, none of the controls would ever get garbage collected, leading to a huge memory leak over time.
Is this a case where you think cycles are appropriate? Or is there a better way to refactor this so it doesn't use cycles? (If someone has ideas for a better design, I would absolutely love to know.)
Reg. your example, I have generally found it effective to model UI hierarchies where the top level components refer to their children 'strongly' while the children refer 'weakly' to their parents. I am not familiar with the recent smart pointer stuff in c++ but I believe that these concepts have been cleanly modeled with abstractions such as this:
http://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/memory/weak_ptr
N.B. A more difficult conundrum that I have encountered when dealing with UI hierarchies is whether or not child components should require a constant reference to their parent passed upon creation or you should be able to 'reparent' or even be in an initial parentless case. My current thinking is that this is a mistake and interactions such as drag and drop are better handled by sending a gesture up to your data layer which then regenerates the component in its new place. This might get ugly, however, if you have a heavily direct manipulation based UI which doesn't really need a data layer on top.
By the way, what has lead you down the road of UI toolkits? They are a fetish of mine. Feel free to shoot me an email if you'd like to connect.
Wow. Overreact much? :-)
Garbage collection works great for one use case: managing heap memory. Please, let's not return to a universe where you need to free each chunk of memory piecewise. That makes freeing memory O(n) in the number of chunks freed, where modern collectors can free unlimited numbers of objects in O(1) time. Compared to this, malloc and free are a little like keeping score in soccer by tracking every action that does not result in a ball entering a net.
The trouble is finalizers. Finalizers suck. They tie the management of one resource (say native memory or file handles) to an unrelated resource (heap memory). This has the terrible consequences highlighted by this story, plus others. It keeps the native resource tied up until the collector decides to run, for one thing. It also harms performance in secondary ways even when the finalizer isn't running. For example, finalizers typically defeat escape analysis, meaning objects with finalizers can't be stack-allocated.
It's a good idea to use finalizers mostly for detecting invalid final states of objects (like leaking resources), as long as you stay aware that finalizers can slow down your program in unexpected ways.
[These are my personal opinions, not those of my employer.]
A GC can't outdo that. For everything the GC frees, it has to do some work to answer the question, "Should I free this or not?" Even if that question can magically be answered with a single CPU instruction, that's still O(n) answers in the number of chunks freed.
However, that brings up a related issue - namely that the JVM requires all (or close enough to all) object memory to be initialized. And given that the amount of memory required to be initialized is at minimum linear w.r.t. the number of objects required to be initialized...
Work done is still O(n) minimum w.r.t. the number of objects allocated regardless.
The thing that is interesting about the asymptotic complexity of garbage collection, though, is that it gives you a peek into the future of GC overhead as heaps get larger.
Consider a program with some bounded steady-state memory consumption, and a GC that takes O(1) time to free unlimited amounts of memory. In such a system, you can reduce your GC overhead arbitrarily simply by enlarging the heap. A larger heap gives a larger time interval between collections, yet doesn't make the collections any slower. Don't like 6% overhead? Fine. Make the heap 10x larger and you have 0.6% overhead.
This time-space trade-off is always available to the end user of such a system. It's certainly not available with more primitive systems like malloc+free.
[These are my personal opinions, not those of my employer.]
So no, I don't see the advantage you say. I see that, in the best case, it's on par with non-GC'd systems, asymptotically speaking.
And yet, I see plenty of disadvantages. To start:
I have yet to see a GC that's O(1) w.r.t. the amount of memory to free. Best case? I'll grant you that, for an extremely naive copying collector. But the chance of that best case occurring is... not significant. Especially with the more sophisticated algorithms.
And again, as above, it doesn't matter how long it takes to free memory. As long as it's linear or sublinear, it'll be dominated, asymptotically speaking, by how long it takes to initialize that memory again. And in steady-state operation it will be reinitialized.
Not to mention the practical effects.
For instance: GC thrashes cache. Badly. It completely kills the concept of a working set. You can't work around that by making your heap larger - if anything it makes it worse. It makes the time period between thrashings longer, yes, but makes them worse when it does happen.
GC also doesn't scale well to large numbers of cores. In particular, your worst case "always" will be when the GC has to check with every core to see if it still has a reference to something. And given that processor numbers are where most of the performance improvements seem to be coming in... You mentioned memory size improvements but didn't mention increasing numbers of cores.
GC also (almost always) has field(s) per object. Minimum of O(1) overhead per object initialized.
Which means that, generally speaking, the overhead doesn't asymptote to zero. It asymptotes to a constant - and non-negligible, at least from what I've seen - amount of overhead.
I'm not saying a fast GC can reduce the cost of allocation. I'm saying a fast GC can reduce GC overhead. I think that's an uncontroversial statement. I can only insist so many times that Java's GC doesn't touch dead objects at any time during its scan. If you want to disagree with me, that is your prerogative.
I agree that a GC walk can thrash cache when it happens. However, a copying GC can also rearrange object layout to improve locality. Which effect is more significant depends on the workload.
I didn't mention the number of cores because it didn't occur to me that it was significant to you. GCs can scale just fine to many cores. No core has to "check" other cores: each core can check its own local data, depending on the tactics employed to deal with NUMA. There are always challenges in scaling any parallel workload, of course, and there are always solutions.
Our GC (in IBM's J9 JVM) uses 8 bits in each object. With classes aligned to 256 bytes, there are eight free bits in each object's class pointer. Hence, J9's object model has one word of overhead on top of the user's data, which is what malloc/free typically needs to track each object's size anyway. No disadvantage there.
[These are my personal opinions, not those of my employer.]
If the unlimited amounts of memory are all in one contiguous block and ALL of them are ready to be free'd (and determining that all of them are ready, takes O(1) time somehow) then what you say is plausible.
In any other case it's fantasy. Suppose I have n variables and I point each of them at a distinct new object (not pointed to from anywhere else). Then I re-set a random subset of them to null. Based on which ones I randomly set to null, there's 2^n possibilities for what the GC must do. If your claimed GC O(1) is long enough for the processor to take k conditional jumps, there are at most 2^k possible results of running it. For n>k, there are necessarily subsets in the above scenario which your GC fails to handle.
>This time-space trade-off is always available to the end user of such a system
People routinely run servers on virtual machines with very limited RAM.
I agree that limited RAM environments are important. Asymptotic complexity only matters when you're effectively operating at the asymptote.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_pointer#C.2B.2B_smart_poi...
My personal experience with similar such systems was that even when performance was not a concern the cost of having to untangle and document my reference structure was well worth the time.
Has any language ever gotten the balance of tradeoffs for finalizers right for strong GC?
Why is that? I would have thought they would work really well together - if an object such as a file stream doesn't escape you could inline and run the finaliser after the last use of the object goes out of scope.
Or do you mean they defeat current implementations of escape analysis?
To make this work, the JIT would need to perform escape analysis on the finalizer too (since the finalizer can make an object escape). If that analysis succeeds, then I suppose the object could be stack-allocated and the finalizer called directly. Even then, though, you would have to think carefully about all the subtle ramifications, like the consequences running a finalizer on an application thread instead of the finalizer thread. (What if the finalizer grabs a lock in an attempt to protect itself from the application code? Now this becomes a recursive lock by one thread, and so both the application code and the finalizer can enter it at the same time!)
If this ever became important enough, it's possible the JIT developers could get this right in every case with enough effort invested. I wouldn't count on that happening any time soon.
[These are my personal opinions, not those of my employer.]
I didn't say synchronization can prevent EA. I said that calling a finalizer on an application thread can defeat the mutual exclusion that would usually be guaranteed by Java's locking. If the app thread holds a monitor when the finalizer is called, that would usually make the finalizer block until the app exits the monitor. If they're on the same thread, that becomes a recursive monitor enter on the same thread, which doesn't block.
Even if you and I solve this particular problem, these are only the problems that occurred to me off the top of my head. With these kinds of subtle, thorny issues lurking around every corner, I wouldn't expect JIT development teams to give this any real attention unless there's some workload where it matters.
[These are my personal opinions, not those of my employer.]
"If (this stuff isn't escaping) then (the JIT can prove that it isn't using a lock)."
That is logically equivalent to:
"If not (the JIT can prove that it isn't using a lock) then not (this stuff isn't escaping)."
Hence, I was explaining that using a lock doesn't count as an escape. But apparently I just misunderstood your meaning?
As I recall, the memory hierarchy was actually simple--the issue was that it called some structure_free(parent) in C++, which freed the entirety of that part of the hierarchy--the parent and the children; which would obviously cause problems if the children weren't done working.
That said, I'm looking over my backups from that era; I can't quite figure out what real code corresponds to the pseudo-code in the post (I didn't have the real code when I wrote the post).
The first issue is that finalizers should NEVER be relied upon to clean up system resources the way that you might in a language with deterministic garbage collection like C++. Instead, expect clients of interfaces that use system resources to manually call some 'close' like method. Use finalizers to warn clients that they are leaking. Josh Bloch has an excellent writeup on this[†]:
http://www.informit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=1216151&seqN...
The second thing, as I believe @btown is saying, is that the child object seems to depend on memory that it doesn't own a strong reference to. I bet the whole memory graph here is just a tangled mess. I used to think that that was just the nature of graphs. When I first started working with GC that couldn't handle these kind of cyclical structures without being explicitly told I thought that it was an absurd premature optimization. Then, this wise old hacker peered at my code, smacked me on the back of the head, and grumbled that if I couldn't clearly explain the reference hierarchy it wasn't just the software that would be befuddled, it was too complicated for his old brain as well.
I'm sure that this can't be true, but I am starting to suspect that all the tremendous work that has gone into fast pause-less concurrent GC has been for naught. I wish that when GC encountered a cycle it would just tell the programmer that they now have a leak, maybe even suggest where it could be fixed with one of those neat little IDE quick fixes, and continue chugging along.
tl;dr When you have a hard problem let someone else deal with it.
[†] Granted, Bloch does make an exception for 'native peers'. My understanding of that pattern, however, is that the key is not letting some other object walk off with a reference to your peer, which is exactly what has gone wrong here.
(Aside: Josh Bloch's Effective Java & Java Puzzlers are fantastic. They are worth reading for programmers who use any language.)