News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Physics in 100 Years by agumonkey on Friday March 27, 2015 @07:44PM (#9279774)
Sussman tried to use scheme as a mathematical notation (http://mitpress.mit.edu/sites/default/files/titles/content/s...) to avoid ambiguities. I don't know how many people saw this, and what the critics were.

The traditional static symbolic notation of math may be the most efficient one, It's constrained, but forces abstraction to emerge. If people had Excel before, we'd never know Gauss sequence sum formula, we'd let the system help us.

Re:Physics in 100 Years by Chinjut on Friday March 27, 2015 @08:06PM (#9279847)
> The traditional static symbolic notation of math may be the most efficient one... If people had Excel before, we'd never know Gauss sequence sum formula, we'd let the system help us.

I think some people in this thread must be using "notation" in a different sense than I am accustomed to. I don't think of the computer's ability to automate addition as an innovation in "notation", per se.

Re:Physics in 100 Years by stan_rogers on Saturday March 28, 2015 @10:48AM (#9281635)
That wasn't Sussman's point. The problem is that the same notational forms -- the same orthographies, if you will -- can mean different things in different contexts. It doesn't help at all that one must, on occasion, slip from context to context in the same argument, producing adjacent or near-adjacent statements that have similar general forms but wildly different meanings. His solution to the problem was to use a notation that also happens to be valid statements in a computer language he had a large hand in designing. That part isn't necessary, but disambiguating mathematical notation by some means is.
Re:Physics in 100 Years by agumonkey on Friday March 27, 2015 @08:27PM (#9279920)
My analogy was borderline, I just think there's value in terse static glyph, and going away from it would be detrimental.
Re:Physics in 100 Years by pakled_engineer on Saturday March 28, 2015 @12:49PM (#9281967)
I skimmed that book to figure out how to convert formulas to procedures in Scheme for learning Spivaks Calculus and a few OCW math courses. Also picked up Doing Math w/Python from NoStarch press to see how other people do this, and to learn Python since I've never really used it. It was definitely awesome to debug logic errors in emacs of formulas I translated, it really does give you a structural interpretation of the material you are trying to learn by coding it all. End result is a library with clear procedures I can use for reference whereas I've already forgotten most of the notation I've learned over the years (SICM uses Spivak's Calculus on Manifolds similar notation)
Re:Physics in 100 Years by smorrow on Saturday March 28, 2015 @06:19PM (#9282957)
All languages have, at least, nouny things and verby things, and a finite(expandable) number of them composable in infinite ways, and I'd say our brains are hardwired for it. So any notation good for humans would have to have this property, which would mean being "equivalent" (in a way) to the language that already exists.

I don't see how any improvement can be anything more than cosmetic.