News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Instrument That's the Key to Electronic Music's Future by yellowapple on Friday March 27, 2015 @05:46PM (#9279232)
Do they support that dynamically, though? I know a lot of high-end keyboards are able to detect how much force is applied to the key and adjust the sound (usually volume) accordingly (i.e. "velocity sensitive"), but these are usually like pianos, where the force is only checked during key press, not throughout the sustain; the CS-80 is instead fully pressure-sensitive (volume will adjust as you ease off pressure or reapply it without having to restrike keys), which is what the article's referring to, and which I've yet to encounter in the wild (though if you do know of a good example of such a keyboard - particularly one that can apply "aftertouch" per-voice like what the CS-80 does - I'd be interested; I've been looking for a good keyboard to add to my shopping list).
Re:The Instrument That's the Key to Electronic Music's Future by drhayes9 on Friday March 27, 2015 @05:56PM (#9279284)
I just bought this tiny MIDI controller: http://www.cme-pro.com/xkey-specs/

On the features list: "Polyphonic aftertouch".

It's a little scary; I thought that was a super common feature and didn't think to check that the one I was ordering didn't support it. I'm glad it does, though.

Re:The Instrument That's the Key to Electronic Music's Future by chipsy on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:19PM (#9279409)
Monophonic(global) aftertouch is pretty common on controller keyboards these days - it's the polyphonic form that is sought after. And there's a chicken-egg problem w/r to its appearance in synthesis programming, since supporting more MIDI events often comes with a little more complexity, and it's only the most configurable synth designs that make it possible to use everything.

In the end, I'm a little sour on any "more is better" approach to control. Breath control is really cool, but it's hardly ever used. Organs have had massive polyphonic range for quite some time, but relatively few people are going to learn to play them. Roland has been marketing the "D-beam" for at least a decade now and it's about as much of a gimmick as ever. There were pitch ribbons on synthesizers back in the CS-80's era, and they occasionally reappear, but the standard is a pitch bend wheel, and that probably isn't just because MIDI dictated a pitch bend. Most music gear is fairly pedestrian stuff, marketed to existing audiences with a coat of paint and a dose of hype, but that doesn't mean it can be revolutionized - the design constraints are mostly ergonomic these days. We want play to be easy and immediately gratifying and to simultaneously control every aspect of the sound, and somewhere in there, a compromise has to occur.

For example, the idea of performing everything by sample playback as the article implies misses how music is mostly driven by performance and how most instruments are basically optimal to play on their own, even if their skill ceiling is high. A commercial multi-sampled violin will have better tone than an amateur player, but you still have to perform with it like a violinist, using appropriate techniques, if it's meant to channel "violin." Otherwise, it'll be another synth timbre. That latter issue surrounding skill and performance is a much broader one with no "obvious" technological endpoint, even when considering AI performance algorithms. Humans will want to play along too.

Re:The Instrument That's the Key to Electronic Music's Future by 21echoes on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:12PM (#9279369)
The Nord Stage 2 (the red one you see in basically every music video/live performace ever :) ) supports aftertouch. If you're looking for something much cheaper than $5k, the Novation Impulse 49 does for $250 (and comes in other sizes, too).