> Magic was selected to win the space
What does that even _mean_?Yes they have money. Can they execute using it? Who the hell knows? Can they execute better than some kids whose uncle gave them £20,000? Maybe, or maybe they'll piss it up against the wall on some stylish offices and seats.
That said, I'm not saying they have won - they've just been marked by Sequoia to do that. That's a hefty thing.
We don't like to admit it because its painful, but the cool kids with the VC money, get the hype, the coverage, the big names C-level executives and the follow investment that are needed to win big. Many fail, but this is how you build a first rate startup.
For example, if Magic grow to £x00m in a year, what would stop Uber adding a similar service to their app? They have the capital, the customer base, the delivery network, and no overhead from using third parties to do the delivery. $12m and a year wouldn't magically beat that.
This isn't an example of a bubble. It's an example of a really comically silly investment.
Whether or not Magic is a smart investment - I can't really tell, but I suspect that if I were to choose between Magic and Twitter back when they were just ideas, I would bet on the former.
Even spaces that are easy to get into and replicate still have winners, household names to rule over all others (Dropbox, Github to name a couple of services that, ignoring scale, can be replicated pretty easily). At the seed stage, investors mark those winners in advance. At later round stage, investors back the de-facto winners (A16Z style). At some point the investment creates a momentum of its own, preventing viable competition and drawing in even more money (all the way to an IPO or acquisition).
The competition eventually dies and if the business case/segment has merit, the winner and their investors will stand to make all the money.
So Magic has just been marked as the winner in their segment (whatever you can call it). Whether or not this service is easy to replicate is irrelevant.