The issue is who is and who isn't included in the definition of unemployed. The truth is, if you don't have a job and you need one, but you've given up your search, you're still unemployed.
The BLS tracks both these numbers.
http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t05.htm
I think half the criticism of the unemployment number is simply because people wish one number could explain everything, but unemployment does not.
Unfortunately it is not measured consistently over long periods of time.
That is why a lot of people look at the payroll report at the same time. But the payroll report usually comes with large revisions.
http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t13.htm
There are 808,000 such people (as of october), up from 484,000 in october 2008.
However, 10.2% unemployment even by flawed definition is still significant.
Even when I took economics in university and we got on this topic, our professor said that it is a very flawed number for such a numerous amount of reasons, but until the government adopts a better way of substantiating, view it as nothing more than a number that may or may not help you gauge the economic climate.
In other words, there is some benefit in understanding our situation with this surveyed number, but you should always question it and the media and government will use it how they please for their own agendas.
The debate on the unemployment rate is very interesting; Google it if you have time and read up.