News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by btilly on Friday November 06, 2009 @03:37AM (#925692)
Penrose contributed a lot and I don't want to minimize that. However when he stepped outside of his own domain he makes some serious basic mistakes that make him ignorable.

As an example in The Emperor's New Mind he makes a number of claims about consequences of Gödel's theorem for human thought that were flat out wrong. I remember reading criticism of it from a logician in the mid-90s, and Penrose's response. While I'm no logician, I know enough about it to know that the logician was right and Penrose was wrong. Human thinking is known to accept inconsistencies and so you can't apply Gödel's theorem to derive any interesting conclusions.

When he moves from logic to physics he is even more out of his depth. Given his verifiable mistakes in logic, I am comfortable in concluding that his startling assertions about physics are far more likely to arise from further mistakes of his than from his having found serious reasons to question the foundations of modern physics.

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by anatoly on Friday November 06, 2009 @04:16AM (#925731)
I agree with your description of Penrose's Goedelian claims (the logician was Solomon Feferman), but I'm not sure why you say he'd be even more out of his depth in physics. Penrose is primarily a mathematical physicist, not a mathematican.
Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by btilly on Friday November 06, 2009 @11:21AM (#926253)
You are right. I had known his mathematical work, but didn't know his biography.

That said, his physics work seems to have been in general relativity, not quantum mechanics. Given what I know about how he messed up when he stepped out of his area in math, I find it more likely that he has made similar types of mistakes in quantum mechanics than that he has truly demonstrated that mainstream physics is wrong.

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by slackenerny on Friday November 06, 2009 @11:50AM (#926339)
not quantum mechanics

Except the twistor formalism he created (following ideas of no one else but Dirac) is important branch of research in quantum mathematical physics and string theory, not only classical gravity.

Just like Hawking or Freeman Dyson had, Penrose too earned his right to odd, and even braggart opinions on everything. Especially since opinions are by definition not meant to advance knowledge, or demonstrate results, but to provoke and inspire discussion.

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by btilly on Friday November 06, 2009 @12:18PM (#926405)
I think Fred Hoyle is a more appropriate comparison. Both did great work that will last in the history books. Both held controversial opinions that were marginalized by the broader research community.
Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by slackenerny on Friday November 06, 2009 @12:37PM (#926451)
Since Dyson contributed half of quantum electrodynamics, and we have numerous Dyson theorems; and since Penrose contributed half of present classical gravity, and we have numerous Penrose theorems, including celebrated Penrose-Hawking incompletness theorem; I think Fred Hole, whose lasting contributions beyond narrating popular books I do not recall, is a fine comparison to Penrose as a pop writer, in addition to mine, perfectly deserved one to scientists of certain calibre who also happen to have some unsubstained and marginalized indiscrete opinions.
Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by btilly on Friday November 06, 2009 @02:31PM (#926717)
Among other things Fred Hoyle (at least learn to spell his name!) was the H in the classic B2FH paper that elucidated the processes by which various elements were created in stars, and explained the relative distribution of different isotopes in the universe.

In my opinion that paper is on the list of the 10 most important discoveries in science in the last century. See http://bentilly.blogspot.com/2009/09/what-makes-it-science.h... for the rest of that list.

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by slackenerny on Friday November 06, 2009 @05:10PM (#927064)
at least learn to spell his name!

Thank you for this most kind and substantial observation. In my defense, Hoyle used to joke of himself like that since concieving his steady-state cosmology where matter constantly flowed out of a "hole"; his autobiography "Home is Where Wind Blows" is also a good read.

In my opinion that paper is on the list of the 10 most important discoveries in science

Took cosmology course (with very distinguished cosmologist) and heard of that in passing. Since then forgotten, sorry (It was that important to me, maybe as a footnote to the αβγ mechanism. Of course this says more about my ignorance than importance of Hoyle's legacy).

So then, I view Hoyle as a crank out of my ignorance, you view Penrose as a crank out of your apparent ignorance. Further discussion would not be a rational argument.

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by zandorg on Friday November 06, 2009 @04:30PM (#926979)
Is that like a black hole? A Fred of infinite density?