News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by BRadmin on Friday November 06, 2009 @03:09AM (#925669)
"In my view the conscious brain does not act according to classical physics. It doesn’t even act according to conventional quantum mechanics. It acts according to a theory we don’t yet have."

Do most modern AI researchers disagree with this?

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by lkozma on Friday November 06, 2009 @03:53AM (#925712)
Yes, most modern AI researchers believe that the functioning of the brain can be explained by electromagnetic and chemical phenomena, accurately described by 1900s theories. The fact that we don't fully understand its workings is due to its organizational complexity.

Penrose's arguments are discussed for example here: http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec10.5.html

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by 10ren on Friday November 06, 2009 @05:31AM (#925793)
It's funny, but to be certain that consciousness can be explained by known laws - we just don't know exactly how - itself requires faith and is quite unscientific.

Although I too believe it.

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by lkozma on Friday November 06, 2009 @06:10AM (#925815)
I see this just as an application of Occam's razor. What Penrose does has been called the "law of minimization of mystery": consciousness is misterious, quantum mechanics is misterious, so why not try to explain one with the other.
Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by randallsquared on Friday November 06, 2009 @07:05AM (#925860)
Few such are certain, in the religious sense. They're certain until new evidence shows otherwise.
Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by rw on Friday November 06, 2009 @03:39AM (#925696)
The sensible response is: "show me ". Quantum effects are not known to be significant. I believe that our mind is an emergent property: lots of neurons and chemicals interacting. Sure, there are a lot of variables, we need the dynamical systems perspective to even begin to understand the whole process... but a new kind of physics? Don't be so anthropic! AFAICT cognition happens at the multicellular level--huge, from a QM perspective.

This reminds me of that old anti-strong-AI bugaboo, "intelligence in the gaps": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by pronoiac on Friday November 06, 2009 @12:54PM (#926496)
Penrose is the odd one out. IEEE spectrum surveilled the field of cognitive science a few years ago, for their Singularity issue - http://spectrum.ieee.org/static/singularity - & he was the only one that felt like that. I was annoyed with him because it seemed he wanted to shoot down the field without even trying, because clearly it would never work.

Max Tegmark looked into the timing required for quantum effects to be significant in synapses - http://space.mit.edu/home/tegmark/brain.html - & showed it was just not required to build an effective model. The rebuttals, such as they are, strike me as tenuous & argued from faith & dogma rather than evidence.

You can see a bit of this back-and-forth at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mind#Ongoing_Debate

Edit: Links, & fixing word wrap.

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by kevinpet on Friday November 06, 2009 @03:55AM (#925713)
If I said that recovering from cancer does not act according to classical physics, or even according to conventional quantum mechanics, you would consider me a delusional wacko with nothing useful to contribute to the conversation.

Given the weight of evidence showing that anything we can measure about the brain can be explained by physical processes, the onus is on the person claiming that's not how it works to point to some phenomenon that isn't well explained by classical physics.

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by frig on Friday November 06, 2009 @10:22AM (#926101)
Generally overconfidence in our present abilities isn't conducive to stimulating new research.

I mean: I give you as much workup on the brain of an unknown individual as you care to have (fMRI, scans, dissection, whatever you want).

Can you detect which languages, if any, the person speaks (or spoke), with any robustness?

Can you detect if the person ever saw an ocelot in person?

Can you detect which sports team, if any, they like or liked to root for, or which instruments, if any, they played?

For most sections of the brain the level-of-detail at which functionality is decoded is still very primitive and coarse-grained. The reason god-of-the-gaps arguments have so much traction is b/c the gaps are still so very large.

Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t... by daeken on Friday November 06, 2009 @03:35AM (#925691)
I don't think we have enough information to say one way or another. We've gained a lot of knowledge about the brain, but it's still very much a black box. I think it's worth holding off on making any assumptions until we understand a whole lot more about it.