News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Confabulation in the humanities by pron on Tuesday March 24, 2015 @07:51AM (#9255989)
> We don't need to call these stories "truths" to do that. No need to muddle up the terminology

And what is that terminology? Even math and physics have different definitions of truth; why can't literature ( literature's use of the word is closer to math's definition rather than physics)? I think most people are capable of accepting different definitions in different contexts.

> I think you misunderstood. It's not that it's not worth knowing. It's that you don't really know it if you can't quantify it.

You don't really know even when you can. The consequence of the Gettier problem[1] is that we cannot define "knowledge" in a way that is both completely satisfactory yet still applies to anything other than math. That is, if we define knowledge narrowly enough to be rigorous and in accordance of our ideal of what knowledge is, we find that we don't know anything. Hence, all knowledge is knowledge to a degree.

> You're just slapping together some explanation to feel better.

Isn't that what understanding means? Suppose we could simulate the entire universe from the Big Bang on extremely fast, and move forward and backward in time in an instant. That would be very useful indeed for some purposes, I guess. Some would even call it knowledge. But would anyone call it understanding? All understanding is meant to make us feel better. :)

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gettier_problem

There are no comments on this comment yet.