News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by sineltor on Thursday November 05, 2009 @11:54PM (#925450)
the point isn't to be right, but rather, to convince others of your position.

Correct. However, he’s not really trying to convince AA to change their strategy. He’s trying to convince us that AA’s strategy is dumb. Because user interface design is important, and its not ok to foul it up.

If the best way to do that is by brashly pointing out AA’s mistakes, so be it. I tip my hat to Dustin for fighting the good fight.

Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by ananthrk on Friday November 06, 2009 @12:17AM (#925480)
the point isn't to be right, but rather, to convince others of your position

He’s trying to convince us that AA’s strategy is dumb

From the article,

Unsolicited designs, if they’re going to be done at all, should be communicated with class, humility, and a ton of research.