News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Confabulation in the humanities by pron on Monday March 23, 2015 @07:45PM (#9254053)
This is interesting and entertaining, but rather than a warning sign, it is just a good demonstration of the limits of our knowledge.

We should not be alarmed that we can only come up with post-facto explanations for the behavior of complex, chaotic systems such as human society, because that is a direct consequence of what they are: complex systems. In fact, we should be alarmed if the opposite were true, and by analyzing current trends, current data, we were able to predict future events. If that were true, then society would be no more than a simple system, completely predictable, whose complete dynamics could possibly be described some closed-form formula.

Re:Confabulation in the humanities by tjradcliffe on Monday March 23, 2015 @09:28PM (#9254392)
The only thing we should be alarmed about is people taking those after-the-fact explanations as being anything more than confabulations, because then people might think they actually understand the world, which is a dangerous conceit at the best of times.

After-the-fact explanations have almost zero epistemic value. They create no understanding, only a feeling of understanding. Look at the financial press for endless examples of this.