News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ESR announces ForgePlucker: solving the data-jail problem... by statictype on Thursday November 05, 2009 @08:23PM (#925219)
esr calls him a fool for his position that meaning can be derived from structure.

I fail to see the difference between that and calling someone a poor programmer based on 1000 lines of prototype code.

Re:ESR announces ForgePlucker: solving the data-jail problem... by mrkurt on Friday November 06, 2009 @01:17PM (#926558)
What you're failing to see is the meaning of the phrase "looks like it was written by a poor programmer". That's a comment on the code only, given that it's possible for a fantastic programmer to write code like that. It's not, however, the same as "calling someone a poor programmer".

Likewise, someone looking at an abstract painting might say "that looks like it was painted by a 5 year old", which doesn't mean they're calling the actual painter a 5 year old. It's commentary on the work.