"A 2001 DSB study calculated the cost of fuel delivered in-flight to be $17.50 per gallon, using USAF provided figures, excluding the capital cost of tankers. Previous studies valued all fuel at about one dollar per gallon."
While it looks like that oversight may have happened before, by 2003 they were looking at something like the real cost of tanker fuel.
As for how that oversight is possible, this report discusses at lengths how evaluating the cost of tanker-delivered fuel is extremely difficult, because how much you use tankers depends a lot on exactly what kind of missions you fly, and a lot of the cost of tanker-delivered fuel is tied up in things like maintenance and operating overhead in the tanker fleet, so to save that 15x multiplier would involve reducing the tanker fleet as the B-52s needed it less, not just the simple act of burning less fuel. The report also mentions that only about 10% of the B-52's fuel was delivered in flight, so while it's expensive, it's not large in quantity. Put it all together and it's sensible to just do a conservative analysis where you assume fuel costs are the price at the pump.
I'm not at all convinced that the relevant factor that changed the outcome of this recommendation was accounting for tanker costs. There are a ton of factors discussed, and it's a complex subject. One obvious factor can ben seen here:
Why did a 2003 study find that more efficient engines were worth the cost, while previous ones did not? I'm not sure exactly when the previous ones were done (this study just says there were three previous ones since 1996) but the fact that jet fuel suddenly got a lot more expensive right around the time this study was being done is certainly suggestive.
In short, when a journalist says "they forgot" what it can actually mean is that in the analysis of a complex problem, a reasonable simplification was made.
http://www.acq.osd.mil/dsb/reports/ADA428790.pdf
A relevant quote from the executive summary:
"A 2001 DSB study calculated the cost of fuel delivered in-flight to be $17.50 per gallon, using USAF provided figures, excluding the capital cost of tankers. Previous studies valued all fuel at about one dollar per gallon."
While it looks like that oversight may have happened before, by 2003 they were looking at something like the real cost of tanker fuel.
As for how that oversight is possible, this report discusses at lengths how evaluating the cost of tanker-delivered fuel is extremely difficult, because how much you use tankers depends a lot on exactly what kind of missions you fly, and a lot of the cost of tanker-delivered fuel is tied up in things like maintenance and operating overhead in the tanker fleet, so to save that 15x multiplier would involve reducing the tanker fleet as the B-52s needed it less, not just the simple act of burning less fuel. The report also mentions that only about 10% of the B-52's fuel was delivered in flight, so while it's expensive, it's not large in quantity. Put it all together and it's sensible to just do a conservative analysis where you assume fuel costs are the price at the pump.
I'm not at all convinced that the relevant factor that changed the outcome of this recommendation was accounting for tanker costs. There are a ton of factors discussed, and it's a complex subject. One obvious factor can ben seen here:
http://www.indexmundi.com/commodities/?commodity=jet-fuel&mo...
Why did a 2003 study find that more efficient engines were worth the cost, while previous ones did not? I'm not sure exactly when the previous ones were done (this study just says there were three previous ones since 1996) but the fact that jet fuel suddenly got a lot more expensive right around the time this study was being done is certainly suggestive.
In short, when a journalist says "they forgot" what it can actually mean is that in the analysis of a complex problem, a reasonable simplification was made.