Re:Security flaw in New South Wales puts thousands of online...
by graeme on Sunday March 22, 2015 @10:37PM
(#9249218)
>Given that we're generally happy to trust online banking, my feeling is that there is a way to make electronic voting secure enough. Where you want to draw that line is subjective though!
I don't think this is the right analogy.
* Citizens constantly monitor their bank accounts
* Citizens are *extremely* upset if an error harms them.
* There are procedures for reversing errors.
* There is a legal system for recourse if errors aren't reversed.
If a party wins an election fraudulently, and gains power, we don't have a good, non-traumatic mechanism for correcting that.Changing $15,000 back to $18,742 is an easy, painless process. Replacing the ruling party is anything but.
Re:Security flaw in New South Wales puts thousands of online...
by jacques_chester on Monday March 23, 2015 @06:57AM
(#9250265)
Note that the screw up was easily observed and there was a mechanism in place to cope. It was also the first time in approximately 100 years that the recovery mechanism was needed.
Show me one system -- one computer system ever -- with a proved, actual (not projected) MTBF of 100 years.
Given that we're generally happy to trust online banking, my feeling is that there is a way to make electronic voting secure enough. Where you want to draw that line is subjective though!