News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fund Manager Ab Nicholas Has Been Beating S&P 500 for 40 ... by jjoonathan on Sunday March 22, 2015 @06:40PM (#9248564)
> assuming a normal distribution of performance

If someone assumes that performance is normally distributed (e.g. by dividing by standard deviation and using the gaussian CDF to reject null hypotheses), couldn't you arbitrage against them by creating a bunch of "heavy tail" funds, waiting for a few of them to beat the market in a more extreme fashion than the normal distribution would predict is possible, and then using the normal distribution to "prove" that it couldn't have happened by chance?

Re:Fund Manager Ab Nicholas Has Been Beating S&P 500 for 40 ... by fsk on Sunday March 22, 2015 @06:49PM (#9248597)
No, because

1. You can't normally short sell mutual funds. As a retail investor, short selling is hard. Plus, short selling has fees, even for institutional investors.

2. Even if a fund gets lucky (or unlucky), its future returns are also normally distributed. I.e, if a fund beats the market 20% one year, its next year is just as likely to be lucky again as unlucky.

Funds that underperform the market severely are closed or merged into other funds.

Funds that get lucky and trounce the market tend to stay open. If your 5 year track record is +20%/year, and you have a "bad" year, your 6 year track record is still +15%/year.