http://cinematicmod.com/images/cm_11/environments/cm_11_18.j...
Wait, why the hell is Alyx dressed like that? Was there anything wrong with pants? It's so incredibly out of place...
That said, Farcry and FEAR were probably the most impressive games from an AI and gameplay standpoint. The physics in Farcry were waaaay better than in HL2.
As far as Far Cry, I'd say it was the one game in 2004 that pretty much had it all in terms of raw technology. Heavy use of complex shader materials, dynamic lighting and shadows, foliage, terrain, water, physics, vehicles.
Though, I would also argue that, despite Far Cry's physics being more robust in a technical sense, the physics in HL2 definitely felt superior when it came to actual gameplay. Probably the result of careful polish more than anything.
In addition to graphics, HL2 was more or less the game that ushered in truly modern physics. Even today, some AAA games don't have physics systems as good. Likewise for facial animation.
There was also Doom 3 that year, though arguably it lacked the same level of fidelity. However, it was really ahead of its time in the years leading up to release.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qj3dPyk7hPI (Doom 3 at MacWorld 2001)