Re:On HN, do you read the comments before you actually click...
by gus_massa on Saturday March 21, 2015 @09:21PM
(#9245071)
I probably wrote that comment.
> especially when there's empirical evidence that shows otherwise.
It's very difficult to explain how hard is to do a good measurement to someone that has never been inside a physic lab. If you have 5V electrical signals up to 100KHz you can be quite confident in your measurements, everything else is more complicated.
It's easier to compare this with another experiment: the faster than light neutrinos.
It was a experiment run by a more serious group, with a lot of specialist and a lot of published papers in that subject. They got FTL neutrinos, and most of the comments here explained that it would break the physics laws and give a alternative explanation of the source of the error. I think I upvoted the wrong explanation :(.
They have a wrong measurement, and a few months later they realized that they have a problem with a fiber optic cable. (Protip: Always check the wires again.)
> especially when there's empirical evidence that shows otherwise.
It's very difficult to explain how hard is to do a good measurement to someone that has never been inside a physic lab. If you have 5V electrical signals up to 100KHz you can be quite confident in your measurements, everything else is more complicated.
It's easier to compare this with another experiment: the faster than light neutrinos.
It was a experiment run by a more serious group, with a lot of specialist and a lot of published papers in that subject. They got FTL neutrinos, and most of the comments here explained that it would break the physics laws and give a alternative explanation of the source of the error. I think I upvoted the wrong explanation :(.
They have a wrong measurement, and a few months later they realized that they have a problem with a fiber optic cable. (Protip: Always check the wires again.)