I wonder: why can the government execute Apollo and Manhattan projects, but botches such simple projects as the Bradley APC carrier?
The software story in "Moon Machines" should be required for anyone who does software. The whole thing should be interesting to anyone; it's a great example of documentary filmmaking.
It is possible to have institutional mechanisms or culture that keeps rot to a manageable level but nobody really knows how to do that deliberately - it's always a matter of luck. That's why it's important to allow organizations to fail. I wish we had some systematic way of allowing that for government departments the way we do for corporations.
Because they were different governments. Yes, they were both labeled "US government", but the brand has changed a lot.
Maybe "First-system" vs "Second-system syndrome" is the difference?
Apollo and Manhattan were definitely "First systems".
Bradley APC and F-35 are classic "Second systems",
suffering from second-system syndrome [1].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_system_syndrome#The_sec...And US urgently needed to catch up in the space race - space is very efficient way to drop nuke on someone.
Of course the Germans were lucky to have lost before the bomb was ready. Otherwise instead instead of memorials at Hiroshima and Nagasaki they might be at Munich and Hamburg.
Victory over Germany wasn't a sure thing until late 1944. The fact that U.S. leadership had the foresight to make a massive investment in the Manhattan Project at a time where half of the US Navy's carriers were out of action speaks a lot of them.
If that was your goal, it is win-win, no matter if the project fails.
And that's where I'd peg the fundamental problem.
And it works with so many companies today as well. That's why I'm a big fan of Tesla and SpaceX - because they build electric cars so that there are electric cars. They build rockets so that humans can go to Mars. Many other companies in these sectors are the toilet-paper type: they develop electric cars to make money on people buying them. They develop rockets to make money on companies buying launch services. It's the difference of having money as an instrumental vs. terminal goal.
For a military contracting specific account: http://www.amazon.com/Skunk-Works-Personal-Memoir-Lockheed/d...
But back then government was at least somewhat independent of the large corps.
Today Washington is the wholly-owned political arm of the mil/ind/fin complex.
The tail isn't just wagging the dog, it's controlling it with direct brain implants.
If you don't accept this, please explain how the F35 was allowed to happen.
The scale of wastage and - let's call it what it is - establishment-sanctioned corruption is almost impossible to comprehend.
Shitshows like the F-35 are just another symptom of the poisonous political landscape. These big projects get jobbed out to hit every congressional district to make projects tough to kill. They turn into monsters that aren't managed by anyone.
In any case, you're suffering from confirmation bias. Plenty of government/large corp work is more than successful, from the SR-71 to Predator drones to the Mars rovers.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA