Re:Trolley problem
by brudgers on Saturday March 21, 2015 @01:50PM
(#9243533)
The problem with the trolley problem is that it discounts time. In the time between throwing or not throwing the switch and the trolley reaching the location of the potential victim[s], our experience gives us some small hope that the victim[s] might be rescued by others. themselves, or trolley malfunction. There is still time for good fortune to replace the bad. The problem does not account for our ordinary intuition in this regard.
This explains the apparent conundrum of divergence in the Fat Man version. If we push him off the bridge, there is no time for good fortune to save him, but there is time for the group to escape, self preserve or get lucky.
This explains the apparent conundrum of divergence in the Fat Man version. If we push him off the bridge, there is no time for good fortune to save him, but there is time for the group to escape, self preserve or get lucky.