News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sabbath mode by mikeash on Saturday March 21, 2015 @01:36PM (#9243471)
The Jewish response to this that I've seen is pretty sensible: if God didn't want there to be loopholes then there wouldn't be any.
Re:Sabbath mode by StavrosK on Saturday March 21, 2015 @02:06PM (#9243593)
The same can be applied to everything, so God wants there to be sin. If God wanting sin to exist means that sin is fine, why are the loopholes necessary? Just sin. If God wanting sin to exist doesn't mean that sin is fine, then loopholes may also not be fine, even though they exist.
Re:Sabbath mode by ars on Saturday March 21, 2015 @09:23PM (#9245085)
You completely missed the point.

God allows sin to exist so that you the person don't do it, as commanded. If God made sin impossible then how can you reward people for following the commandments?

The loopholes are different - God did not say "don't try to find loopholes, God instead made very specific commandments, with clear holes in them".

You are mixing physical impossibility with carefully studying and following the commands.

Re:Sabbath mode by oh_sigh on Saturday March 21, 2015 @10:13PM (#9245224)
How do electric circuits correspond with commandments made in the BCs?
Re:Sabbath mode by DanBC on Saturday March 21, 2015 @10:25PM (#9245250)
One reason: "Is it fire?" -- see also the Feynam chapter "Is Electricty Fire?"

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_on_Shabbat

EDIT: this is an NSFW site and might be dodgy. http://www.e-reading.mobi/chapter.php/71262/46/Feynman_-_Sur...

> A footnote: While I was at the conference, I stayed at the Jewish Theological Seminary, where young rabbis—I think they were Orthodox—were studying. Since I have a Jewish background, I knew of some of the things they told me about the Talmud, but I had never seen the Talmud. It was very interesting. It’s got big pages, and in a little square in the corner of the page is the original Talmud, and then in a sort of L-shaped margin, all around this square, are commentaries written by different people. The Talmud has evolved, and everything has been discussed again and again, all very carefully, in a medieval kind of reasoning. I think the commentaries were shut down around the thirteen– or fourteen– or fifteen-hundreds—there hasn’t been any modern commentary. The Talmud is a wonderful book, a great, big potpourri of things: trivial questions, and difficult questions—for example, problems of teachers, and how to teach—and then some trivia again, and so on. The students told me that the Talmud was never translated, something I thought was curious, since the book is so valuable,

> One day, two or three of the young rabbis came to me and said, “We realize that we can’t study to be rabbis in the modern world without knowing something about science, so we’d like to ask you some questions.”

> Of course there are thousands of places to find out about science, and Columbia University was right near there, but I wanted to know what kinds of questions they were interested in.

> They said, “Well, for instance, is electricity fire?” “No,” I said, “but… what is the problem?”

> They said, “In the Talmud it says you’re not supposed to make fire on a Saturday, so our question is, can we use electrical things on Saturdays?”

> I was shocked. They weren’t interested in science at all! The only way science was influencing their lives was so they might be able to interpret better the Talmud! They weren’t interested in the world outside, in natural phenomena; they were only interested in resolving some question brought up in the Talmud.

Re:Sabbath mode by wolfgke on Saturday March 21, 2015 @08:09PM (#9244851)
Couldn't it be, that God wants sin to exist, so that he can punish sinful people (come on, it's probably lots of fun for him ;-) )?
Re:Sabbath mode by ams6110 on Saturday March 21, 2015 @08:52PM (#9244997)
Or because, if it's not a matter of free will, faith and worship is meaningless.
Re:Sabbath mode by ars on Saturday March 21, 2015 @09:34PM (#9245121)
The Talmud specifically asks why God created sin and the answer is so that God can reward people.

Do you enjoy punishing people? Or do you enjoy doing nice things for people? Why would you think God would be worse?

Re:Sabbath mode by StavrosK on Saturday March 21, 2015 @08:15PM (#9244875)
Yes, it can. And he may also similarly punish people who use loopholes.
Re:Sabbath mode by cssmoo on Saturday March 21, 2015 @01:40PM (#9243488)
If there was a god he'd probably be facepalming.
Re:Sabbath mode by reuven on Saturday March 21, 2015 @04:58PM (#9244186)
Actually, there's a famous story in the Talmud of a rabbinical debate in which the rabbis argue about whether a certain oven is kosher or not. At the end of the story, one of the rabbis is told that God's reaction to this debate is, "My children have defeated me."

The Jewish attitude is that God wants us to debate these laws, and that if we come up with interpretations that seem counter to the literal verses in the Bible, then that's totally OK. The rules were given to people to interpret, and now it's up to us to do that as accurately as possible.

Re:Sabbath mode by cssmoo on Saturday March 21, 2015 @05:50PM (#9244317)
Actually that's really interesting. Thanks for the detailed reply.
Re:Sabbath mode by ZanyProgrammer on Saturday March 21, 2015 @08:17PM (#9244884)
Except for Karaites...
Re:Sabbath mode by reuven on Saturday March 21, 2015 @08:33PM (#9244934)
Ya know, we were always taught about Karaites in school, but I didn't realize that they still existed until about 20 years ago, when a friend mentioned that he knew one.

There is a Karaite community in Israel, and I've read some fascinating newspaper articles about them. Claiming that they only accept the literal word of the Bible, without any interpretation, is a bit far-fetched, given that the Bible is so ambiguous and self-contradictory. But some of their interpretations, such as the date of the Shavuot holiday, are pretty reasonable -- except that Jews have basically voted with their feet to reject those interpretations.

I think that Karaites are pretty cool, even if (or perhaps because) they're not mainstream. And they demonstrate, I think, Judaism's penchant for pluralism.

Re:Sabbath mode by ZanyProgrammer on Monday March 23, 2015 @10:38AM (#9251142)
There's one nearby in Daly City, CA. Though alas being LGBT I don't think there's any analogue to Reform Karaism!