Re:Replacing Photoshop with NSString
by vbezhenar on Saturday March 21, 2015 @01:30AM
(#9241949)
I wonder what's better from the point of final user (app size, app starting speed, app performance, memory usage): png or this drawing code? I suspect that PNG should work better. And programmer can easily generate multiple PNG from single hand-written SVG.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Not speaking about processing costs, this could be nice format for storing the data. Consider the example from page:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
a · 1 2 · · · ·
b · A # # · · ·
c · · # # # · ·
e · · · 9 # 3 ·
f · · · 8 # 4 ·
h · · # # # · ·
i · 7 # # · · ·
j · 6 5 · · · ·
It is textually 58 characters of data: 7 ·12·····A···············9·3····8·4·········7······65····
(Axis headers and whitespace ommited, two characters added to keep the row width information.)It is almost the same size of the smallest possible SVG polygon of similar shape consisting of 59 characters:

Re:Replacing Photoshop with NSString
by charles_parnot on Saturday March 21, 2015 @04:05PM
(#9244024)
Nice to see the actual comparison of the binary size (and there is the 2x and 3x png). On the other hand, to be fair, the memory footprint will be more with the ASCII version (text + final NSImage loaded as bitmap in memory) compared to png (only the bitmap in memory, directly loaded from disk). The size of the bitmap is big anyway: there is no compression.
Re:Replacing Photoshop with NSString
by charles_parnot on Saturday March 21, 2015 @02:26AM
(#9242010)
Yes, PNG is probably using less memory. For a few small icons, though, it's negligible either way.
Re:Replacing Photoshop with NSString
by matiaspiipari on Saturday March 21, 2015 @10:17AM
(#9242772)
If speed / memory is of essence, it's simple enough to pre-render this .asciimage kind of data with the code @cparnot has made available at https://github.com/cparnot/ASCIImage. I whipped up a quick commandline tool for the purpose as part of https://github.com/mz2/ASCIImage-Super-Studio:
https://twitter.com/mz2/status/579283430858465280
It could of course be rendered to a PDF or TIFF or other Cocoa supported image file format, consider that just a 5-minute hack to demonstrate the idea.