Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by stingraycharles on Thursday November 05, 2009 @11:07AM
(#924032)
You're forgetting one way more important thing: logs. Your access patterns to Google's sites is way more important than the information you see on this dashboard; based on your access patterns, most of the information in that dashboard can be predicted anyway.
Sounds like they have no intention of sharing the logs or cookie-related data either. We're still expected to simply trust that they're sufficiently anonymized and not actually linked back to our google accounts.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by alain94040 on Friday November 06, 2009 @12:45AM
(#925521)
We're still expected to simply trust that they're sufficiently anonymized
Actually Google fought in court to make sure that it didn't have to anonymize its logs, ever. So it's a safe bet to assume that your logs are not anonymized.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by alain94040 on Friday November 06, 2009 @11:54AM
(#926349)
Sorry, I wasn't clear. After 18 months, they don't keep the original IP anymore, that is correct, but they can still cross-reference everything. Which means that in practice, they can still figure out who you are, they haven't lost any "connectivity" of the data.
But to make regulators happy, after 18 months, they can't spit out your raw IP addresses. Feel better now?
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by stingraycharles on Friday November 06, 2009 @02:46PM
(#926764)
That makes me wonder what "anonymous" actually means. As I understand it, Google anonymizing the logs in fact means they don't store any information that can lead directly back to you: as in, based on a single log file, they couldn't say who you are.
In the greater context of things, however, it is not anonymous: based on your previous access patterns, and your current (< 18 months) access patterns, they could link your anonymized logs with your unanonymized logs. Is that still anonymous then ?
This all reminds me of some research from Germany I heard about a few years ago: basically, if you have someone's ZIP code, age, gender and education, you can get a > 99% accuracy resolving who this person is in real life.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by jberryman on Thursday November 05, 2009 @03:34PM
(#924700)
To riff on that: i chat with friends on gmail. For a few of them, I've input their phone numbers into the gmail chat interface so that chats will be sent as SMS when they're not online. A few of them use GOOG411 frequently for directory assistance. Now google, if they care, can draw from the data of a user's GOOG411 calls, to feed them more relevant ads on their site.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by stakent on Thursday November 05, 2009 @01:26PM
(#924371)
There are other places where Google gathers lots of information about you: blogspot, youtube, all sites using Google Analytics, all sites serving Adsense ads, all sites serving doubleclick ads, all sites using Google Analytics.
So:
Clear your cookies.
Use tor.
Don't forget about flash cookies.
Don't forget that your computer's real time clock skew can reveal it's identity. By examining packets sent from it.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by dennisgorelik on Thursday November 05, 2009 @03:10PM
(#924649)
Why is that a problem that Google knows about you?
Google knows about me a lot, and I think it's a good thing, because:
1) I might be found by relevant people.
2) It adds up to my reputation, for example it may help to send email and have it delivered, because I look like a real person.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by stakent on Thursday November 05, 2009 @04:02PM
(#924758)
Yes, there are advantages being known online.
But we are not talking about about search results. We are talking about wide and not controlled by us stream of data stored somewhere.
Risks for a user?
For example exploiting one's weaknesses by, in most trivial case, serving her ads or search results tailored to push her to make desired action.
I, personally, prefer to build my online image by taking my own conscious actions, not by data hungry algorithm running by corporation which goal is to maximize shareholder's value.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by 3dFlatLander on Thursday November 05, 2009 @10:59AM
(#924011)
I logged in thinking there wouldn't be very much on me, since I had disabled web history when the feature first came out.
It seems to have "reactivated" itself around October 2009 for some reason. Also, despite google telling me they only collect web searches, my history for image, news, and video searches are also included.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by brewski on Thursday November 05, 2009 @11:19AM
(#924061)
Under Account I clicked on "Websites authorized to access the account" and saw that clickpass had access to my Google Contacts. Why do they need access to that?
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by healsdata on Thursday November 05, 2009 @04:59PM
(#924880)
Logging in to HN using Google prompted me to give Clickpass access to Google Contacts. Logging into StackOverflow with Google doesn't do that, so maybe Clickpass is using an old/weird method of Google auth?
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by maukdaddy on Thursday November 05, 2009 @10:16AM
(#923916)
Wow it is really sobering to see how much information one company has. Now imagine this spread across all the businesses you interact with on a daily basis.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by jrockway on Thursday November 05, 2009 @12:34PM
(#924238)
The credit reporting agencies don't actually verify any of that information, so most of it is junk. Apparently my "legal name" is "Johnathon Rockway". Yeah...
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by jrockway on Thursday November 05, 2009 @02:09PM
(#924491)
Google collects its own information, so it is in control of the quality. When you pull someone's credit report, you don't know if what's listed is entirely accurate, and you don't know what it's omitting. So there is a difference.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by fuzzmeister on Thursday November 05, 2009 @05:58PM
(#924986)
I'm not sure it should be that easy - if you left that page open and walked away for one second someone could delete all of your mail, calendars, documents, pictures, blog posts... the works.
"The Data Liberation Front is an engineering team at Google whose singular goal is to make it easier for users to move their data in and out of Google products."
They provide information on how to "escape" from a particular service ie. download/migrate data from that service. However, I can't find any indication of whether there is a way to permanently delete all your data from their servers.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by teeja on Friday November 06, 2009 @05:08AM
(#925776)
That's a Good Thing. Ever spent a year adding data to a site (like oh, say, Stumbleupon) only to notice that there's no way to get your work out? I did. DL lets you export to several other blogformats. That's much cooler.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by trjordan on Thursday November 05, 2009 @11:22AM
(#924066)
I find it interesting that there is so much redundant and conflicting information in there. Mine has 3 different addresses, from the last three places I lived (and hadn't updated).
I understand that they are all different services, but since they're all controlled by Google, why not add something to sync them? I'm pretty comfortable with all the information that's up there, so why not have the information constant, and leave the privacy settings down in the individual applications?
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by ComputerGuru on Thursday November 05, 2009 @12:19PM
(#924203)
A while back, I did everything I could to clear my YouTube account settings. Something I did apparently broke their code, and now YouTube viewing history is disabled.
There is no option to disable YouTube viewing history in the preferences on either YouTube or Google, but somehow, thankfully, YouTube no longer records my video history. :)
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by jrockway on Thursday November 05, 2009 @12:31PM
(#924233)
Back when I worked at Doubleclick, the answer was "not much". We were not legally allowed to store your IP address, for example. (But, of course, we could store the md5 hash of your IP address. I love the legal system.)
I am more worried about Analytics, which provides details of everything you do on nearly every site on the Internet to one centralized source. Needless to say, this is the reason why I have NoScript installed.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by greyman on Thursday November 05, 2009 @11:26AM
(#924076)
Basically, all the Google services you subscribed to, like Gmail, Alerts, Blogger, Youtube, Calendar, Docs, Health, how many Picasa Web Albums uploaded, what is your recent favorite Youtube video, recent Task, or your recent Web History (disabled for me).
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by tome on Thursday November 05, 2009 @12:35PM
(#924240)
I don't have any information about any searches I've done on google.com (and I definitely have done them!). Is there something special I need to do to see that info?
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by mlok on Thursday November 05, 2009 @10:45AM
(#923979)
Not much interesting about me.
I am happy not to have relied too much on Google for the last decade. God knows it can be difficult sometimes.
Temptation is high.
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by trebor on Thursday November 05, 2009 @10:51AM
(#923986)
I use Google products, but not that much. The simple point is to: opt out of what you don't need. I use GMail, predominantly, and beyond that don't have much other information associated with my account.
Privacy online isn't threatened by Google ... so much as it is by PEBKAC. ;-)
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by jrockway on Thursday November 05, 2009 @12:33PM
(#924235)
Yeah. I can't believe Google has the calendar entries I typed into Google Calendar. They could show up at my next dental appointment and serve me a targeted advertisement!
Re:Google Dashboard: This is a brief of how much Google know...
by JoeAltmaier on Thursday November 05, 2009 @11:30AM
(#924088)
I use(d) only Google Docs, and it tells me
"Detailed information from this service is unavailable at this time."
Absolutely typical, which is why I abandoned it for other collaborative file sharing tools. Also I hit my "share quota" whatever that is. Typical of Google toys - not ready for a production environment. I know its free, but I can pay for real tools that don't fail me randomly (or as much anyway).
Sigh. Didn't mean to rant. Sorry.
Sounds like they have no intention of sharing the logs or cookie-related data either. We're still expected to simply trust that they're sufficiently anonymized and not actually linked back to our google accounts.
Actually Google fought in court to make sure that it didn't have to anonymize its logs, ever. So it's a safe bet to assume that your logs are not anonymized.
We anonymize this log data by removing part of the IP address (after 9 months) and cookie information (after 18 months).
But to make regulators happy, after 18 months, they can't spit out your raw IP addresses. Feel better now?
In the greater context of things, however, it is not anonymous: based on your previous access patterns, and your current (< 18 months) access patterns, they could link your anonymized logs with your unanonymized logs. Is that still anonymous then ?
This all reminds me of some research from Germany I heard about a few years ago: basically, if you have someone's ZIP code, age, gender and education, you can get a > 99% accuracy resolving who this person is in real life.
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/6623
So:
Clear your cookies.
Use tor.
Don't forget about flash cookies.
Don't forget that your computer's real time clock skew can reveal it's identity. By examining packets sent from it.
Funny times to live?
What are the downsides of Google watching you/me?
But we are not talking about about search results. We are talking about wide and not controlled by us stream of data stored somewhere.
Risks for a user?
For example exploiting one's weaknesses by, in most trivial case, serving her ads or search results tailored to push her to make desired action.
I, personally, prefer to build my online image by taking my own conscious actions, not by data hungry algorithm running by corporation which goal is to maximize shareholder's value.
Edit: added missing not in first paragraph
It seems to have "reactivated" itself around October 2009 for some reason. Also, despite google telling me they only collect web searches, my history for image, news, and video searches are also included.
Now I feel slightly uncomfortable.
I think it may have something to do with making money.
> Now imagine
Uhm - have you ever checked your credit report?
> so most of it is junk
How is this a logical progression? And does google "verify" any of its information?
"The Data Liberation Front is an engineering team at Google whose singular goal is to make it easier for users to move their data in and out of Google products."
They provide information on how to "escape" from a particular service ie. download/migrate data from that service. However, I can't find any indication of whether there is a way to permanently delete all your data from their servers.
I understand that they are all different services, but since they're all controlled by Google, why not add something to sync them? I'm pretty comfortable with all the information that's up there, so why not have the information constant, and leave the privacy settings down in the individual applications?
What a terrible design choice, assuming the intent is to make it easy for users to see how much of their personal information is out there.
For anybody frustrated by this behavior, the way to force it into English is to append ?hl=en to the end of the URL.
There is no option to disable YouTube viewing history in the preferences on either YouTube or Google, but somehow, thankfully, YouTube no longer records my video history. :)
Apparently I use Google a scary amount :D
I am more worried about Analytics, which provides details of everything you do on nearly every site on the Internet to one centralized source. Needless to say, this is the reason why I have NoScript installed.
looks over shoulder
Privacy online isn't threatened by Google ... so much as it is by PEBKAC. ;-)