Re:Pharrell Williams: $7.3M Blurred Lines verdict threatens ...
by geebee on Friday March 20, 2015 @01:06PM
(#9238893)
I don't think the scenarios are all that similar.
The first is about taking a precise and full replica of a copyrighted work and putting it on a file sharing system.
The second is about borrowing, perhaps heavily, from a copyrighted work to create a derivative work.
I don't think it's necessarily inconsistent to consider the first infringement and the second fair use.
If it's not "Look! Pirates! We're all going to die!!! We need to strengthen copyright NOW!"
Then it's: "Ouch! I lost a copyright lawsuit! We're all going to die!!! WHO is responsible for this insanity?"