Re:Ask HN: How is it fair that companies ask candidates to s...
by lukevella on Friday March 20, 2015 @11:13AM
(#9238185)
I don't agree that using other industries as examples is a good defense. Just because everyone is doing it doesn't make it right.
Obviously the more work a person puts into a task, the better you can assess their ability. But when does a task become excessive. It seems that the limit is being stretched thin.
Is it fair? I'd say yes, if following 2 conditions are met: 1. The method (AC/task/exercise) is well designed to actually test the candidate's skills and his/her performance is properly observed, measured, analyzed and assessed. It's fair for the candidate, because the hiring decision is adequate. 2. After all this effort the candidate receives both a "thank you" and short feedback about his/her performance.
Unfortunately these conditions aren't met quite often and that's not fair.