If you've gone to Yale for 8-10 years and have a PhD in Business Management, then yeah, you have skills which most people will never have. As such, they have certain abilities and insight most other people don't.
I don't think that this is relevant to their ability as an executive. In the same way, I generally don't see PhDs being good developers or engineers. In some cases it denotes passion, but more and more these advanced degrees seem to only signal a desperation to get a piece of paper and an inability to escape from a fairly exploitative and abusive system.
It's like the pyramid schemers (I mean network marketers) who make claims about how you too can have all that sweet passive income. No, the structure only allows for a small percentage of the overall population to sit at the top, no matter how 'lucky' or 'skilled' an individual is.
Yes, there is only so much room in these kind of schemes at the top.
However, I don't buy this statement that "skill" is not involved as I have seen certain people simply rebuild these kinds of networks over and over.
There is a real skill in being able to work a weak, but large social network.
To some degree I agree with you.
Some of the most profitable companies I've worked for have very shrewd CEO's. I worked at a bike shop when I was still in college (Eriks Bike Shop). The guy started his business when he was 14. When I worked there, he still only had around 10 stores. One of the smartest things he did was get real estate in smaller areas, off the beaten path and grow his customer base. Once he had a big chunk of the market, he'd close those stores and open a bigger shop right off the highway, near the old store. He also had a very close knit group of people at the top. As far as a I know, it's still just him, the VP of sales, the head IT guy and one other guy. Less than 6 guys effectively now run 22 shops in two states and do multi-millions in sales every year. Erik never went to college, and started this right out of high school. A good example of someone without the groomed skills you're talking about.
The other places I've worked, like most of the bigger fortune 500 companies, they usually had Ivy Leaguers who either had PhD's in either business or economics or both. To me, these skills aren't overrated. If you've gone to Yale for 8-10 years and have a PhD in Business Management, then yeah, you have skills which most people will never have. As such, they have certain abilities and insight most other people don't. To me this makes them uniquely qualified to run large businesses. Not just their degree, but also the market and business insight expertise is crucial. Sometimes I don't think you just get that from working in a certain industry for a certain period of time.