For any public related service actually, that is regulated. Any software written for a car, truck, train, bus, airplane is regulated in terms of certification by so-called notified bodies.
Bitcoin would've never been possible if a software engineer required a licence to write financial software. And it is a very critical piece of software.
International company valued in the billions ignoring regulations that local (per-county) companies with typically less than 5 cars can't afford to ignore (because they immediately lose their license).
If this is about regulations, Uber could have tried to go the legal route (apply for licenses until they're refused, then go to court over it, unlike our solo drivers they can afford the lawyers). They have the money. Instead they want to decide which laws apply to them.
Yes, local businesses may suffer. But at the same time, the big bully actually makes it cheaper and more affordable for the consumers of that country to have that service. "Everyone's" got kids and families to feed, so to speak - including taxi passengers. Why is it that I should be more sympathetic to the local taxi drivers and not to the local passengers, who'd be saving money?
Uber does none of that, and the only reason why they can afford that is because they're incorporated elsewhere and have deep pockets.
If they cared for the markets they enter, they would have realized that in Germany the 'monopoly' story is factually false. They might even have realized that the regulations provide a loop hole that they could use to start operating in some counties/cities to prove that their service is useful.
They did none of that. Just grandstanding, posturing, and then crying like babies about how everybody is unfair to them when they're held to the same standards as everyone else.
This isn't even about prices (the ones our elected officials set for taxis are quite reasonable, and they don't feature 'surge pricing'). It's about Uber's conduct.
That's not sustainable. I knew self-employed taxi drivers and they weren't exactly rich, far from it. Having to give some leech 20% of their income would have ruined them, so Uber's presence in their business model must be to the detriment of someone.
So if they survive and corner the market, they'll raise prices (all those VCs want a return, after all). If they don't, they may leave behind ruins where there was infrastructure - no interest in that. There is no option 3, since their business model is fundamentally 'us vs them': Serving all the good inner city and airport routes, while leaving the non-profitable stuff to someone else doesn't work for long.
I can understand that Uber doesn't want to plan for the long term: They might not be around in 3 years, and even if they are, any mess they create here doesn't affect them.
I'd prefer infrastructure to still work in 15 years, and Uber doesn't look like an ally for that cause. In fact their conduct indicates to me that they wouldn't hesitate to burn down society as long as they can instate themselves as rent keeper and make a buck on the remains. Why should I support that?
Nobody forces Uber to enter the German market. If they can't rethink taxis legally, they should leave the field to those who are capable of that (to those who want to: PBefG ยง2(7) might be of interest).
tl;dr: don't buy taxi services on society's credit card - since I believe Uber customers are doing that when they get 'cheaper' service, any restriction on Uber is a good thing in my book.
Taxis are regulated for a reason. I want to know that when I get into a taxi, the vehicle is roadworthy. I want to know that the driver is competent and medically fit to drive. I want to know that he isn't a convicted rapist. I want to know that his insurance is still valid when carrying paying passengers. Uber provides none of those guarantees, but intelligent regulation does all of that without creating a significant barrier to entry.
If you want a safe taxi, by all means, use the government approved service. I for one couldn't care less, so I'm gonna go with a cheaper service. Everyone should have that choice.
Road traffic is dangerous. Not only for people sitting inside those cars, but also very much so for everyone else.
The pedestrian your cheap taxi without working brakes just ran over didn't choose your taxi.
You did. And you're proudly saying that you have assessed the risk and... are willing to let other people take it.
I'm amazed that there are actually people who think it should be okay to drive around uninsured, so when you hit a pedestrian and he ends up a quadriplegic and in need of constant care, you just say "oh, I'm sorry, take all the ten thousand Euros I have and good life to you!".
I'm certain you'd see the stupidity of your point of view if you were the quadriplegic without any compensation.
Fortunately, in Europe we don't let those people learn their lesson the very hard way. We do the sensible thing and just demand insurance from everyone. Including self-proclaimed libertarian rebels against the system.
It is my choice whether to insure myself or not. It is the choice of the driver whether to insure himself or not. It is the responsibility of the road owner to demand all cars have insurance. Unfortunately, we mostly have only one road owner these days: government. If you had plenty, then some would allow uninsured cars and some wouldn't. Then it would be up to both drivers and pedestrians to use those roads (this is one possible solution).
You're trying once again to draw an image of a libertarian as a ruthless individual who doesn't care about the misfortunes of other people. I do care very much about that and I would be happy to help out. What I am against is FORCE with which government demands people operate in the market very often against their will.
Some people are riskier. Some people are careful. As long as it doesn't affect another person, everyone should be free to do whatever the hell they want.
Finally, your elitist standpoint "we in Europe" is simply disgusting to me. I apologize for this emotional outbreak, but I have zero respect for collectivism. "You in Europe" are all different and by saying it they way you did, you simply disrespect people who have opposing views, not considering them a part of your society.
I'm almost always on the side of less governmental power, but to believe that all regulations like these are unnecessary is just boneheaded.
But you do. And when you choose to use a public service, you should obey the rules set forth by the governing body of that public service. What you are suggesting is that you have the right to decide what to spend your money on, but when others do it, it's wrong.
You are the one complaining about using public infrastructure and having to follow the rules when using it.
The point is to allow people to make their own choices. What you're advocating is depriving people of the choice of how to spend their money and manage their risk/reward options.
You want other people to suffer a higher risk, just so you can save money.
And no matter how often you try to frame it as a matter of "I choose for myself", you're actually choosing for others.
That's highly illiberal and unfree, by the way.
Software runs the world these days, you can't just let people with no licences write shitty code. Politicians and bureaucrats should join their forces and decide whether each individual programmer is of a certain level. If not, he is banned from writing code and should be fined or imprisoned if he ever tries to do that.
Or let's regulate musicians. You know, it would do good. I'm so tired of all these useless crappy bands that write all the same music, thinking they are different. Even though I don't listen to them I also think others shouldn't be listening to them too, as this influences people's tastes in a direction I cannot approve of. So yes, licences for musicians!