The expected lifecycle of an engagement ring is one engagement. Getting her something "used" would be even worse than something "fake".
And diamonds are a heavily depreciating asset. A car loses about 10% of its value the second you sign the purchase contract. With a diamond ring, it's more like 60%.
If this kind of gift is made to be symbolic of your relationship, then a car (or any other heavily depreciating asset) isn't the best symbol.
One of my friends got an olive tree for her 25th wedding anniversary. I thought that was a great gift.