> And frequently they won't, leading to fragmentation. This happened a lot before the GPL became de rigeur.
What time frame are we talking about? My experience was that the GPL probably was at its most popular in the late 90ies, but has gradually declined since then. Most things these days - Rails, Node, Android, Go off the top of my head - seem to have more permissive license.
People are a lot more connected now than even 20 years ago, so contributing back is also much easier. Also, more people get open source, at least for infrastructure type projects.
And Keith Packard frequently regretted X11 being under a permissive license, given how much company forked work the home project never saw code from.
It is easier to give back now, this does help.
Try now. Mac OS X is based off BSD and contributes little back (and what it contributes is patent-encumbered enough to be unusable). And that's only a high-profile example which is obvious: there are tons of examples we'll never hear about because we'll never see the code.
It's not that hard these days, particularly if you are a big company with plenty resources, Apple chose to fork Clang/LLVM so that they could keep their Swift implementation proprietary.
>Rails, Node, Android, Go
Haven't open source frameworks pretty much always been permissively licensed ?
My experience is that applications are typically GPL licensed, meanwhile frameworks and libraries are typically permissively licensed.
And frequently they won't, leading to fragmentation. This happened a lot before the GPL became de rigeur.