News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What you wanted to know about AI by davmre on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @11:14AM (#9218447)
That's not the definition the mainstream AI community has taken, for what I think are largely good reasons, but you could define intelligence that way if you wanted. It's only a renaming of the debate though - instead of calling the things we're worried about "intelligent machines", you'd now call them "very effective control systems".

The issue is still the same: if a system that doesn't perfectly share your goals is making decisions more effectively than you, it's cold comfort to tell yourself "this is just a control system, it's not really intelligent". As Gary Kasparov can confirm, a system with non-human reasoning patterns is still perfectly capable of beating you.

Re:What you wanted to know about AI by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:24PM (#9219038)
Yeah you can imagine a lizard brain being introduced into a biomechanic machine to calculate chess moves. It doesn't make a lizard more intelligent, or even add intelligence to the lizard.

If we don't regard intelligence as something different from control, then I guess birds are the most intelligent because they can navigate complex air currents. Etc. That is a poor definition of intelligence, because its not helpful in distinguishing what we normally mean by 'smart' from mechanistic/logical systems.

And the discussion of rogue AIs is all about intelligence gone awry. Does anybody fear a control system that mis-estimates the corn crop? No, its about a malicious non-empathetic machine entity that coldly calculates how to defeat us. And that requires more that the current AI's are delivering.