News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @08:35AM (#921618)
suggesting that copyright is vital for innovation and creativity is just silly

You realise there are no CC licenses without copyright. That anyone can take my published work and reprint it as their own without any attribution.

Copyright has been much abused by big business, but that's capitalism at work, we shouldn't disavow people of the rights to an interest in the results of their labour.

Copyright only works as a contract between creators and the public. We're doing our part by protecting rights of content creators via the treaties and laws but we are being denied our part of the contract - having works enter the public domain in a timely fashion.

Copyright IMO needs fixing not removing.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by sp332 on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @04:29PM (#922644)
"You realise there are no CC licenses without copyright. That anyone can take my published work and reprint it as their own without any attribution."

That's the natural state of things. Changing the social relationship between artist and fan, unilaterally for a whole society as copyright has done, better have some darn good reasons. I am not convinced it's worthwhile.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @06:24PM (#922856)
Well historically copyright was created (Statute of Anne) to empower authors to retain rights of reproduction for a limited period so that they could profit from their work over and above any profits made by mere printers. Prior to that works remained hidden from the public domain or were bought by publishers outright who agreed amongst themselves not to interfere with one anothers monopoly right to reproduce the work - this was largely a technological restriction, there was [virtually, save transcription] no self-publication.

I still believe that encouraging people to create works by ensuring they have a limited monopoly on commercial exploitation in return for eventual expansion of the public domain is worthy and workable.

If you create a communist society then I can see how copyright is not needed, in the current climate of commerce where I am in Europe (at least) complete dissolution of copyright IMO is to the public detriment.

One simple example might be how to finance a proper dictionary, or indeed any academically rigorous reference work, without allowing the creators of the work the chance to profit from it? How would that work, in say a capitalist society, under your regime?

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by sp332 on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @08:18PM (#923082)
If no one wants a dictionary, then no one will pay for it to be written. That's the same now as under my regime. My idea is, if someone wants a dictionary, they would either write one or pay someone to write one. It's still pretty capitalistic. The same people pay for it, there's just more haggling and risk involved.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by pbhjpbhj on Monday November 09, 2009 @05:07PM (#931850)
The first copy I sell as the commissioner of the dictionary could be the last - an alternative printer can buy that copy and produce a far-far cheaper copy (no production costs except blind reproduction). He will have the market and I will have nothing but bankruptcy.

How many people will pay a few million dollars for a dictionary to be made and then allow copies to anyone else? Copies will be sold with contracts for very high prices and with no chance of entering the public domain except by breach of contract.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by uriel on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:31PM (#922245)
> Copyright has been much abused by big business, but that's capitalism at work

Rubish, copyright is completely incompatible with capitalism: copyright consists of government granted monopolies.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @05:52PM (#922789)
The "capitalism at work" part is the manipulation of copyright to prevent works from entering the public domain. The motive is corporate profit: ensuring those with property retain it and any worth it can generate despite a socialist contract agreeing to give up that property after a certain period.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by uriel on Friday November 06, 2009 @11:29AM (#926273)
That is not "capitalism at work", that is rent seeking and one of the many very common forms of government failure.

Just because the motive of something is profit, it doesn't mean it is capitalism, the motive of taxes is also profit (for special interests), but that doesn't mean they are capitalism at work.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by pbhjpbhj on Friday November 06, 2009 @10:28PM (#927438)
The stated motive of taxes is usually the public good; if it's profit for special interests then you're probably talking of fraud.

I still contend that the pressure by corporations to increase copyright terms in order to maximise the profitability of held IP assets is "capitalism at work". It is sustained holding of IP away from the public domain preventing others from using that IP [for profitable production]. Smells like capitalism to me.