News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by ghshephard on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @12:13AM (#921080)
Joel is definitely talking about Atlassian in this article. In particular, one of their products, jira, goes head-head with FogBugz. Joel has actually referred to them in previous articles, in terms of customers threatening to go to the "Australians" if he didn't implement such-such a feature. (http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2009/07/20.html)

Atlassian is really the Major Grower in this space - good sized developer community, and "App Store" equivalent (Plugin Exchange ) - They have about 50,000 plugins a month downloaded from a library of 400 - 130 of which are for Jira.

The latest rev of their product, Jira 4.0, has one major feature - a SQL like query engine, they call it "JQL" - Jira Query Language - which allows you to do everything you might expect/imagine. Their searching was _already_ better than FogBugz, but JQL makes you not even not want to compare the two.

Interesting Notes:

Google for "Bug Tracking Software" doesn't bring up FogCreek, but does bring up Atlassian.

Atlassian is like the "Anti-Fog Creek" in terms of it's thoughts around office. I've been to their San Francisco Offices (which are supposedly like their Sydney) - One Big Wide Open Space. No Cubicles. No Offices. Nothing - just pure Agile openness.

Go to Atlassian.com - you are 4 Clicks away from having the software on your computer, and it takes about as many seconds. And it figures out whether you want OS X stuff, linux files, etc...

Go to FogCreek.com - 30 seconds later I _still_ couldn't figure out where to click to try their stuff - and when I do, I finally land on a page where I need to start providing Email Addresses, Phone Numbers, accepting terms of services. It's almost like they are _daring_ you to try the competition.

What's cool, is that _both_ Fog Creek and Atlassian are the ultimate results of Startups going head-head. Someone will have to write a book about these two companies.

http://www.atlassian.com/about/history.jsp Atlassian: "In 2002, fresh out of university, Scott Farquhar and Mike Cannon-Brookes, With total start up costs of $10,000 charged to a Visa card, they built JIRA, a professional bug and issue tracker, and Atlassian was born. By 2004 the company had grown to six developers."

http://fogcreek.com/About.html Michael Pryor founded Fog Creek Software with Joel in September 2000.

Fog Creek's Major Problem, and the reason why I suspect Atlassian is going to wipe them out if they don't get their Act Together, is that Fog Creek has, to my knowledge, three products:

  o Bug/Project Management/Software Project Tracker (fogbuz)
  o VNC Hosting Service for Tech Support (Copilot)
  o Forums for Software Developers/SysAdmins StackOverflow/ServerFault
  o 25 Employees
Atlassian, on the other hand, has:

  o Issue Tracking Software (jira)
  o Wiki (confluence)
  o Source Code Reviewer (fisheye)
  o Code Review (crucible)
  o Continuous Integration (bamboo)
  o Code Coverage (clover)
  o Identity Management (Crowd)
  o 200 Employees
  o 15,000 Customers
  http://www.atlassian.com/about/customers.jsp
I don't want to come off sounding like an Atlassian fan-boy, particularly as I love reading Joel's articles, and I don't think I've ever read anything, ever, out of Atlassian that caught my attention - but he has his work cut out for him. Of course, maybe Joel needs someone like Atlassian to shake him up and get him going...
Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by ghshephard on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @12:43AM (#921128)
Interesting to look at their pricing for jira vs fogbugz - Clearly each of their pricing (for anything but the smallest companies) is almost the same - basically they discount the software and profit off the maintenance contracts):

Fog Creek: $10,000 + $5000/year Atlassian: $8,000 + $4000/year

http://fogcreek.com/FogBugz/PriceList.html http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira/licensing.jsp

But, Atlassian is smart, and gets you when you are small:

  50 Person Software Shop:
  Atlassian: $2200 + $1100/year
  FogCreek: $8000 + $1825/year
And, what if you are a small startup - Where FogCreek/Atlassian were 2 Years after they were founded,

  10 Person Software Shop:
  Atlassian: $10
  FogCreek: $1899 + $365/year.

Given that the products are _roughly_ equivalent, and the customer has decided for some reason not to just use Bugzilla or Trac , which product do you think your typical 10 Person Small Software Shop will install.

Or, if you are using Bugzilla, but you are a cranky release engineer, and you want to replace it with something with a little more horsepower (not to mention benefiting from the QA/Regression of all those customers of Atlassian/FogCreek) - which product do you think you might be able to get away with expensing.

Now, finally - You have grown from 7 engineers to 20 Engineers - there is a CLOSE TO ZERO chance that you will EVER switch from FogBugz to Jira (Or Vice Versa) - But, Jira is starting out with a lot more customers, so they experience a profit wave.

Basically by the time the companies grow to 100 Users (where FogCreek/Atlassian are making profits off of the Maintenance, as it's been 3+ years since anyone has called for support) - Atlassian has a much bigger slice of the pie. This does NOT bode well for fogcreek in the coming years, as all of that Atlassian market share finally starts to pay dividends, further accelerating their growth, allowing them to invest more in their product, and further gaining market share...

And that, is one major reason why Atlassian is growing faster, and eating Joel's lunch.

Ironic, given the essays that Joel has written on pricing. I realize that he probably doesn't want to price his product at $10 and make it sound "cheap" - Atlassian was brilliant, and they did the following:

"Get started for $10 All proceeds go to charity" - "www.roomtoread.org" - it's like they READ Joel's article and said to themselves "Well, we can't cheapen our product to gain market share, but we _can_ raise money for charity"

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by Carlfish on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:22AM (#921180)
While your analysis of why we're doing the $10 deal is spot on, we only introduced it a couple of months ago so any benefit we might see is still in the future. Previously the cheapest edition of JIRA was (if I recall correctly) $1200.
Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by ghshephard on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:48AM (#921217)
Actually, Atlassian has a Reputation, well deserved, of being very socially conscious. When I went to the Atlassian San Francisco Social a couple weeks ago, Scott Farquhar seemed most excited and interested in talking about the Room To Read program. The "Stimulus Program" (The $5 Personal License from back in April) raised north of $100K and provided a year of education / costs for 68 Cambodian girls, helped build some libraries, and published a story book.

It's nice to see that doing good things in the world can also be profitable. (Al Gore just got my company on the front page of the NYT today doing the same thing - so I dig it. :-) )

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by johns on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:27AM (#921188)
A couple additional points that aren't readily available:

1) Fogbugz has an integrated wiki, but I don't know how it compares to Confluence and you can't get it separate from Fobgugz.

2) Fog Creek has a code review and hosted Mercurial source control product that's in beta called Kiln.

3) You can get FogBugz on Demand for free with the student and startup edition, but that's only for 2 users.

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by gommm on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @03:15AM (#921306)
Wow the 10 person software shop promotion is interesting... I'm currently starting a company and was looking for a good issue tracker.

Up until now I've been using fogbugz for other projects but the license is a bit steep when starting up...

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by Poiesis on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:01PM (#922167)
Hilarious. Joel's said previously that site licenses and volume discounts are a bad idea ("Bad Idea #1: Site Licenses. "):

http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/CamelsandRubberDuckie...

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by ghshephard on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:23PM (#922231)
Yeah - but what is he going to do when his primary competitor offers Site Licenses?
Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by nl on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @04:32AM (#921381)
"I don't think I've ever read anything, ever, out of Atlassian that caught my attention"

In the old days Mike Cannon Brookes used to blog a lot. I think there is a good argument that Atlassian did more to save the Java platform (back in the dark 2001-2003 period) that any other company (including Sun).

They started javablogs.com, which back then was the real hub of open source java development. That encouraged Sun to start their blogging push, and that engagement was what protected Java against what seemed back then to be the inevitable rise of .NET. (Obviously the JBoss open source project and Apache/Jakarta had a lot of influence then too, but Atlassian was the most visible company during that period)

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by holdenk on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @02:55AM (#921290)
Maybe you and I are using different local Google's but for me googling for "Bug Tracking Software" both with and without quotes brings up Fog Creek in the first 5 (as of Nov/3/09). On .com atlassian is 2 bellow Fog Creek. On .ca it brings up Fog Creek right after atlassian
Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by ghshephard on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @03:08AM (#921302)
Apologies - I was unclear and misleading. I meant to say "The Advertisements" for "Bug Tracking Software" don't show Fog Creek, but do show Atlassian.
Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by ctrager on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @09:25AM (#921694)
Joel has been and seems to continue to be anti-paid advertising. I've heard him say it on the Stackoverflow podcasts, and I know it from trying to get FogCreek to advertise on my website (I tried again after having read the Inc article, thinking that maybe he was born again...).

I think he overestimates how well known FogBugz/FogCreek is. I think he unnecessarily handicaps himself with that policy.

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by swilliams on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @06:42PM (#922889)
I'm helping a new non-profit startup get going and we ultimately went with Atlassian stuff since we just plain and simple cannot afford FogBugz.

I've used FogBugz and like it quite a bit, but the email response I received from them basically reiterated what was on their website: no discount for groups over 2 people.

If FogCreek came up with something competitively priced as Atlassian's "starter pack" I'd consider switching, but there is also a significant cost of moving all the data over the more we grow.

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by ghshephard on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @02:29AM (#921260)
Another Data Point that it is Atlassian he is talking about:

2004, 6 Employees -> 2009, 200 Employees = 100% Annual Growth, as quoted in the article against FogCreek's noted 50% Growth.

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by michaelneale on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @05:46AM (#921457)
And its all about bug trackers. Gosh this is a boring business fight to watch - well I guess its slightly less trivial then facebook apps ;)
Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by ctrager on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @09:34AM (#921720)
As a developer, I say not trivial. This isn't just about bug trackers, because bug trackers integrate with version control, maybe our IDE, and soon code review tools.

A bug tracker can be like email, on the screen all the time, with a lot of our communication with co-workers going thru it ( and in fact the good ones incorporate email into them very well. )

So, it's the software we are living in. Next to our text editor, it's maybe the MOST important software.

Not counting Pandora, of course.

Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by michaelneale on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @07:19PM (#922957)
Yes I probably didn't meant to say trivial, it just seems that bug trackers are so cliche to talk about (doesn't mean they aren't important).
Re:Spolsky: Does Slow Growth Equal Slow Death? by lucifer on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @08:00AM (#921561)
From the history article:

"In addition to eschewing traditional enterprise software, the company forged a different sales and marketing model, relying on word of mouth and selling their products online without the use of an outbound sales force. The company remains private and has no institutional or venture capital investment."