Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by Kalium on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:07PM
(#9209579)
Rent control wouldn't be such a problem in SF if it didn't also lead to NIMBY-ism preventing the addition of more housing.
I didn't call anyone silly. I said the idea that economics cease to apply because strong emotions and italic fonts are involved is silly.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by tptacek on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:42PM
(#9209697)
Even without NIMBY-ism, rent control keeps new housing from being built, because it makes the return on investment for new housing uncertain. People generally don't build apartment buildings out of the kindness of their hearts.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by maxlybbert on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:32PM
(#9209664)
"Externality" means something more than "thing I don't like."
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by tptacek on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:36PM
(#9209677)
That's a bit of a snarky way to put it, but this is correct; the parent comment is abusing the term "externality". The consequences of rental contracts for tenants in a free housing market are not an externality; the tenant is a party to the transaction.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by glesica on Friday March 20, 2015 @12:08PM
(#9238523)
In this case, the tenant isn't a party to the transaction, the tenant can't afford to be a party to the transaction at $8,000+ per month, that's my whole point.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by foobarqux on Monday March 16, 2015 @12:25AM
(#9209859)
Housing prices and displacing people from their homes has an obvious effect on the local labor market, which is an externality.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by Kalium on Monday March 16, 2015 @12:30AM
(#9209872)
Given that they are displaced by other people, presumably with higher incomes and skill levels, I'm not sure how obvious an effect that is.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by foobarqux on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:13PM
(#9215453)
A city's inhabitants aren't fungible even in SF and in any case replacing employees costs a company a lot of money.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by chongli on Monday March 16, 2015 @12:30AM
(#9209873)
No, but there are serious externalities involved when classes of people are driven out of communities.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by davidw on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:49AM
(#9210574)
They perhaps they should consider building more housing. With the bonkers prices there, I bet even with a portion dedicated to low income housing, stuff would still get built, as long as the rules were clear.
Taking away someone's home involves potentially massive negative externalities (emotional and otherwise). Therefore, if you want to maintain the political theater that says capitalism is designed to benefit everyone, you have to accept that it may be preferable, optimal in fact, to incur some deadweight loss. Rent control is one strategy that does just that: as long as a person lives in a place, the rent can't go up.
Is it naively optimal? Nope. But it is (or can be, if you get the implementation right) actually optimal. It is a guarantee that a house can be a home, if the tenant so chooses, and it could be used to balance the aforementioned negative externalities.
Does it? Who knows, maybe, I'm not familiar enough with San Francisco's housing laws. Just because they implemented it poorly doesn't mean the concept is unsound or irrational and it doesn't mean that anyone in favor of the concept is "silly" or deserves to be condescended.