News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by sago on Saturday March 14, 2015 @05:37PM (#9204274)
I've been fortunate to anti-work all my life. I've started companies, built technology, made sales, written books, and generally got paid well to do what I love. I've anti-worked very hard. Often 15 hour days for months on a new project. I have a spouse who is a homebird and provides me the flexibility and support I need for that. In return I support the household. I've been reasonably successful. Not rich, but I have a home, a residual income, assets, I can buy nice things, and buy nice experiences. I can provide for my children and give to charity.

There are plenty of people who work, who work more than one job. They turn up, are told what to do, are at the mercy of the politicking of the organisation, get paid poorly, are physically exhausted, are pressured into moral compromises, have little medical or mental health support, have no assets or qualifications to be able to escape, and are well aware they would not be able to find anything substantially better. Perhaps they work 10 hours a day, then go home, cook for their kids, put them to bed, do the laundry and clean and crash.

When people try to compare my effort against those people, and say "look at people like him, he's proof hard work is the road to success!" I find it morally obnoxious.

The lie that work is the road to success is perpetuated by those who are able to anti-work, to maximise their own success on the backs of those who can't.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by themartorana on Saturday March 14, 2015 @07:45PM (#9204698)
Most importantly is that many of those people shouting about the virtue of work are enjoying anti-work on the backs of those working harder than ever. I don't know if it's actually malicious, or just an echo chamber (there have been plenty of studies that show that the more money people have, the more they feel they deserve to be in the position they are [0] - this of course being a generalization and not an accusation of parent), but it certainly seems like a degree of Ostrich Syndrome when it comes to acknowledging how the efforts of many often benefit the few.

Edit: forgot link

[0] http://blog.ted.com/6-studies-of-money-and-the-mind/

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by sago on Saturday March 14, 2015 @08:40PM (#9204839)
The idea that someone can claim they deserve their success because they worked so hard, when 'work hard' just means 'spend long-hours doing something they were intellectually and emotionally engaged by' seems so transparently egotistic.

On that basis, most successful people I know almost never work hard.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by themartorana on Saturday March 14, 2015 @09:30PM (#9204969)
I spent a summer working on a peach farm in the packing house. It was hard work. The next summer I worked as a life guard at a private club, which was over all incredibly easy (and I got paid more). It was transparent which life I'd rather lead.

Fast forward 20 years, and as "hard" as I work in software and mobile games, it's never been as soul crushing as working on the farm for minimum wage, with absurdly strict owners. (I once got yelled at for looking at the clock on the wall behind me when we were in a lull.)

My now father-in-law has been a farmer for 60+ years. He has never had much money and still works the fields.

He works hard. I'm pretty sure I only did once, 22 years ago.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by danieltillett on Saturday March 14, 2015 @09:43PM (#9205006)
I feel the same. I have worked in agricultural jobs and it is really hard work - work so hard that even when young and fit you end the day so tired that you want to sleep as soon as the sun goes down. About the only positive out of this experience is it does make me really appreciate the cushy lifestyle I have now :)
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by thret on Saturday March 14, 2015 @11:12PM (#9205210)
It depends though. I have a friend who bought a winery+vineyard after he retired, he's losing money and working very hard but he's also happy. I've spent a day out at his farm, pruning vines and getting shown around his equipment and all the things he's excited about. We ended the day with a big family BBQ on the veranda and so much wine... pretty good retirement if you can afford it.
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by danieltillett on Saturday March 14, 2015 @11:29PM (#9205252)
Buying a winery is a good way to turn a large fortune into a small one. I love visiting wineries, but doubt I will ever make enough money to own one.

There is a big difference between working on your own property in your retirement and working piece rate earning under the minimum wage for 14 hours a day of back-breaking physical labor.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by cglace on Saturday March 14, 2015 @11:02PM (#9205178)
I'm the opposite. I worked landscaping for a few years and loved the fresh air, blue skies and working with my hands.
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by danieltillett on Saturday March 14, 2015 @11:32PM (#9205260)
I have bank of large windows in my office overlooking a sea of green that I can open and enjoy the outside weather. I don’t think I would be too happy being in some basement under fluorescent lights year round.
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by golergka on Sunday March 15, 2015 @04:50AM (#9205869)
> on the backs of those working harder than ever

As a software engineer — no I don't. Sometimes I feel bad about earning a lot of money doing what I love, but at the same time, I know for sure that I don't exploit anyone, and that I got where I am only thanks to my own work. Yes, it's unfair that the world needs more software engineers than artists right now, and if I loved art more than code but that doesn't mean that I exploit anyone.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by e_proxus on Sunday March 15, 2015 @05:01AM (#9205883)
You most likely do. The hardware you use is probably manufactured under much more severe conditions that under those you work. And what about the raw materials required to produce that hardware? Some of those are probably mined under much more harsh conditions.

The same goes for the clothes you wear, the food you eat etc. (though, to be fair it is easier to consciously buy better food and clothes today than hardware).

I often felt bad working in the software business because of the issues with hardware manufacturing. You can buy locally produced clothes and food, and you can often figure out under what conditions they are made under. With hardware, not so much.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by StavrosK on Sunday March 15, 2015 @06:44AM (#9206052)
That's a bit disingenuous. By that logic, everyone exploits people, so the baseline just rises to that, making the GP's statement "I didn't exploit any more people than everyone else", which is more or less true.
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by golergka on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:53AM (#9206304)
Yes, I use products that are made by people that fare worse than me. This statement will stay true forever for any member of the middle class, unless humanity will get rid of money, and enters post-scarcity economy of Star Trek (which would've been called communism, if wasn't such a loaded world). But it doesn't mean that I exploit those people in any way.
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by countrybama24 on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:24AM (#9206589)
You are the customer of those who do exploit those people though. We're all complicit in this, but I think it's equally disingenuous to wash one's hands of all exploitation in supply chain they benefit from simply because they don't directly make the decision to exploit someone. You're fortunate to work in an industry where workers have enough leverage to combat the exploitation rampant in other industries.

And it is not inevitable, we could end (or at least minimize) the violent, chaotic exploitation without needing a post-scarcity economy in my opinion.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by golergka on Sunday March 15, 2015 @12:22PM (#9207012)
> those who do exploit those people though

I don't think that a majority of these people are exploited. Some are, and it definitely happens more often than to people like you and me (going from the assumptions that hacker news is a website for software developers, I have trouble picturing a developer who falls into "really poor people" category), but still — not always. More often it's just market reality that create these kind of conditions.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by quanticle on Sunday March 15, 2015 @05:34PM (#9208250)
>I know for sure that I don't exploit anyone,

You might not directly exploit anyone, but you (and I) are making tools that make it easier for others to exploit people. I mean, let's take Amazon's warehouses, for example. Would Amazon be able to push its warehouse workers as hard it does without the software that manages inventory and tells warehouse employees exactly where to go and when? I doubt it. But that software didn't magically spring into existence. It was written, by a team of programmers and iteratively improved until it allowed Amazon to push its warehouse workers as hard as it does today.

So no, we software developers not exploit anyone, but that doesn't mean that we're not complicit in exploitation.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by jokoon on Sunday March 15, 2015 @05:51AM (#9205959)
> on the backs of those who can't

So, do you feel guilty ?

I have no mercy for people who work hard and pretend they deserve more because they're not unemployed. I'm unemployed, but I'm not living comfortably, and I honestly cannot fathom the idea of obeying someone because I should "contribute" because that's righteous. I live in france, there's a lot of welfare there, unemployment is at 10% (the U3 stat), workers are treated nicely, but there's a lot of hypocrisy about it.

I don't think most people cannot "antiwork". Work is not mandatory, work is consented. People can negotiate their salary. If nobody does, I'd agree to blame the entire society and its citizens for not standing up to higher standards. Slavery has been abolished, but slave wages show that people now consent to be treated like shit, so to me, people are responsible of their own situations.

In my opinion, if people agree to be treated like slaves, let them be treated like so, and let the other laze away. We live in the 21th century, people should not give up so easily on their life.

I'm tired of people arguing that capitalism and free market are virtuous, while a large majority of people are being paid at the minimum wage. Minimum wage doesn't feel like freedom, it feels everybody is treated the same no matter the contribution. It's not free market anymore, it sounds more like an exploitative society that can't lift individuals out of their poverty.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by jasim on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:08AM (#9206714)
You are quite lucky to live in a time and place where humans are treated well and without the shackling notion of productivity. But it has less to do with your personal agency and more to do with your luck. People can be made responsible for their situation only so much. Individuals are powerless before the collective idea of normalcy of the society they live in.

Steve Bruce puts its nicely in his book "Sociology: A Very Short Introduction" - None of us personally created the social institutions that shape our lives; we were born into them. The roles that structure our behaviour and encapsulate the expectations that others will have of us preceded our arrival and will endure (no doubt slightly modified) after we depart. Reality may be socially constructed, but, taken in its totality, it is not the work of any nameable individual and it certainly has little or nothing to do with any one of us.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by jokoon on Sunday March 15, 2015 @06:16PM (#9208437)
> You are quite lucky to live in a time and place where humans are treated well and without the shackling notion of productivity.

You say that, but when you're poor and society talks you down by arguing that you only get what you deserves, it feels like you're cheating and behaving like a stubborn thug.

At the end of the day, I put so much pressure on me, I ended up believing I was mentally ill, and it enabled all sort of self confidence issues and distorted views on society.

> Reality may be socially constructed, but, taken in its totality, it is not the work of any nameable individual and it certainly has little or nothing to do with any one of us.

I still have trouble projecting my lonely self in that big scheme that is human society. This whole civilization seems scary and often too full of things I'm scared of.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by loup-vaillant on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:00AM (#9206193)
Don't underestimate network effects. If most people consent to being treated like shit for a lousy pay, those who don't will be singled out. Which makes it even harder to stand up for yourself… well you get the idea.

Demand better terms by yourself, and you will simply be dismissed as entitled, arrogant, or not knowing your place. Have everyone demand better terms, and you will all get them.

Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by jokoon on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:40AM (#9206433)
I really think it's a vile effect. Consensus is the worst thing about democracy, it should not repress minorities or people who don't subscribe to groups. That's what the silent majority is all about. I really believe we should protect individuals, not society or groups of people, who often get taken over by bullies.
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by StavrosK on Sunday March 15, 2015 @06:40AM (#9206046)
Consent is a slippery notion. If the choice is between a shitty job and homelessness, did you really consent to the shitty job? It's a tragedy of the commons, people do what's best for them individually while making society as a whole worse.
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by jokoon on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:42AM (#9206441)
Well yeah, that's why the role of democracy is to work towards the mutual interests of individuals...
Re:Antiwork – a radical shift in how we view “jobs” by partition on Saturday March 14, 2015 @09:04PM (#9204901)
This is also known as value _creation_ versus value _transference_:

http://halfsigma.typepad.com/half_sigma/2008/03/value-creati...

I do not completely agree with the guy's views; in particular I do not believe in there being anything other than value transference, and value "creation" means you are closer to physics, transferring value at a physical level, than to politics and sales, transferring value from other people. But it does cut the bullshit.