However, I do expect well founded definitions and operations. To define an operation on two vectors and not point out that it isn't a vector while stating that the geometric algebra is different "from all other associative algebras" is misleading. Associative algebras are closed under the operations they have. So something ought to be said about the peculiarity of talking about associative algebras while not having an operation that is closed.
The only paper I've read from Hestenes is the paper in question and the perspective I have is that of a mathematician. My comment only dealt with this paper and from my perspective things were muddled a bit. He talks about confusion of physics students in graduate school on the topic of vectors. I'm assuming such students will eventually have to deal with tensor products and the exterior algebra when they study general relativity. Hence my belief that one should talk about the larger algebraic structure from the get go rather than glossing over the fact that the geometric product of a two vectors is not a vector and the mystery of squaring a wedge product.
Scalars + bivectors are isomorphic to the complex numbers provided the base field is R and the isomorphism is as vector spaces not as algebras or rings.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clifford_algebra#Introduction_a...
For that, see his numerous other papers and books about the subject, or the several books by other people in the last 10–15 years.
It’s unfair to label this expository sketch “mathematically unsound” on the basis that it skips a bunch of steps... when there’s no space to be fully rigorous in the context.
> On page 9 he discusses what he calls the geometric product. The problem is that the geometric product of two vectors is not a vector. This means that the space he is really working is larger than the vector space he started with. This isn't explained to the reader. What is this larger space?
Anyway, you are absolutely correct that the geometric product of two vectors isn’t a vector: instead, it’s a scalar plus a bivector (scalars + bivectors form a space isomorphic to the complex numbers, conveniently).
You might notice that the conventional inner product (dot product) of two vectors is also not a vector. Likewise, while the cross product of two vectors is defined to be a vector, it’s not really the same type of vector as the two original vectors and must be treated differently, causing endless confusion, especially for students. Reducing this confusion by clearly embedding geometric products of vectors in a larger space is the whole point.
For more, see:
http://geocalc.clas.asu.edu/html/Evolution.html#References
http://geometry.mrao.cam.ac.uk
http://geometricalgebra.net
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geometric_algebra